Gig Review: Grace Elizabeth Harvey supported by Matthew Dodd

By Xavier Newbery

Folky, playful and painfully honest, Grace Elizabeth Harvey and Matthew Dodd enchanted the Claypath Deli audience with original music, covers and duets.

Alongside staples like the yearning ‘Familiar’, Grace showcased new songs from her first EP, ‘Other Faith’. Moving us through the modulations of love, Grace explores its banality in ‘Diane’. Meanwhile, she soars to an almost operatic climax on ‘Good Night’. With his intricate, ambling guitar and vocal melodies, Matthew Dodd’s witty lyrics spin feelings of loneliness and contentment in a new light.

Opening with the wistful ‘Travel Song’, Matthew crafted a traveller narrative of loose endings and beginnings with his delicate lyrics. ‘Paris tried its best,’ but failed to assuage the speaker’s blues. Clad in a stripy blue shirt and corduroys, he delivered his set with an endearing awkward charm. Introducing ‘St Stephen’s Day’, he remarked, ‘You don’t often get boxing day songs. So I wrote one.’ However, his self-disparaging humour did not obscure the seriousness and melancholy of these tunes. Held back but also pushed forward by his ‘historicizing creaking heart’, a world of liminal anxieties and small joys emerges; lines like ‘like ‘the waters rise like memory or time’ recall the image-driven, straightforward style of Bob Dylan or Joni Mitchell.

Matthew’s wordy style is complemented by intricate fingerpicking rhythms that tease out the tensions in his melodies

In a similar space, ‘I’d like to get to know you (like you’d like to know yourself)’ wanders between major and minor sounds, asking whether you should ‘sterilise your future with the promise of relief’. Quirky lines like ‘tandems of tautology’ prop up, expressing how lovers can become synonymous with each other; he echoes light and airy vocal phrases on the guitar as he muses upon dependency and self-love. After a questionable Simpsons joke, he leads the audience into the darker side of love with the ‘36th Street Boogie’. Fingerpicked, low, warm and pulsing, the rhythm drives towards loose ends, asking, ‘how and when you intend to die’, lamenting how ‘the words that kept us only tear us apart’ which he rhymes with ‘sub-letting a portion of your heart’.

Matthew’s wordy style is complemented by intricate fingerpicking rhythms that tease out the tensions in his melodies. After these reflective tunes, he jumps into ‘Richard Ayoade’, a comical song his friend wrote after a first (and at the time, seemingly last) date. Delivered charismatically, Matthew’s flows easily as his sweet, musing tunes bleed into each other. His occasional slips with certain sections of songs might be a point to improve on, but this is overshadowed by the emotional subtlety and variety of his set.

After several duets with Matthew, Grace opens her set quietly with ‘Lullaby for Wasted Time’, the opening track from ‘Other Faith’. She lets guitar notes hang in the air, not afraid to let emotion linger as she laments calling for her lover ‘into the blue’. She spins love in an exciting way with charged lines like ‘I’ll never forget the day / I learned I love you was an awful thing to say / It’s terminal and washed away’. This wallowing, meditative tune leads into ‘Birdsong’, which was inspired by a singing exchange with a bird in Flass Vale, County Durham. The existential, philosophical lyrics ponder, ‘when was it that humans began to sing?’ as the impulse to make music leads her to conclude ‘I’m a songbird that will never reach the air’. The repeating, fingerpicked chords that flow through the song create a sense of surprise and an uplifting motion every time the chorus comes around.

Eschewing structural norms, Grace’s musical sections slip into each other, allowing for her hearty, ashy voice to soar above the guitar accompaniment. She allows musical space into her songs, allowing her lyrics and ethereal melodies to linger in the audience’s mind.

Eschewing structural norms, Grace’s musical sections slip into each other, allowing for her hearty, ashy voice to soar above the guitar accompaniment. She allows musical space into her songs, allowing her lyrics and ethereal melodies to linger in the audience’s mind. ‘Good Night’ stands out as a perfect example of this, sending shivers down my spine as she launches into an almost operatic lament. Finality imbues the lovers’ separation: the coming of winter, and the journey away from ‘love’s charms’ pushes over the cascading ‘I watched you fall / like ash in the night’. Mostly conjunct, the melody becomes disjunct and leaps with confidence in this instance. This song reveals a mastery over melody, pairing a Leonard Cohen-esque accompaniment with Jeff Buckley-like melodies.

Moving on with her set, she explains how falling in love has ignited her life and music. On ‘Sandy’, boldly begun with a tense, diminished chord, she uses repetition to craft musical patchwork, conveying the image of her lover’s sandy hair. ‘Diane’ explores the commonplaces of love, tinging love with anger and pairing it with booming guitar and vocals. Strange natural imagery props up like a ‘rabbit’s foot and silver chains’ as Matthew Dodd joins her on the harmonica, vamping melancholic notes exquisitely. The performers feel connected in their duets, exuding a charming emotional vulnerability and openness when they play. Grace’s ends her set with the lowing, ‘Familiar’ and a cover, with Matthew, of Paul McCartney’s ‘Heart of the Country’, as they wash away the pertinent melancholy of their lyrics with mirth.

Image Credit – Grace Elizabeth Harvey