Habemus Progress! The Catholic Church blesses same-sex unions
By Callum Tilley
The Vatican has announced that Catholic priests are now allowed to bless same-sex unions in religious settings, providing that this blessing does not replicate the sacrament of marriage still reserved for heterosexual couples. This comes just years after the Pope refused to allow this same measure, indicating a shift in the Church’s stance towards homosexuality. Whilst this is by no means an endorsement of homosexuality, nor a signal of widespread, grassroots acceptance, it is a sign that even the Church is coming to see the untenability fully rejecting the LGBT+ community. This about-face is surprising for Catholics worldwide. As only as recently as 2021, the Church’s doctrinal office refuted the possibility of blessing homosexual couples, with the report arguing that God “does not bless sin”. Lately, the Pontiff has signalled major support for the LGBT+ community, with the Pope hosting gay and transgender Catholics for lunch and, when asked about gay priests, retorting “who am I to judge?”. Arguably, this is the latest stage in the Pope’s mission to modernise the Church’s approach to sexuality and render the institution more accepting.
This shift can be explained by a couple of converging factors. The Pope, now eighty-seven, is increasingly facing medical scares. It is possible that this is an effort to overhaul the Church before he is replaced by a successor that may not share his progressive drive. Furthermore, following the death of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, perhaps Francis feels more at liberty to act as he would wish, without the conflicting authority of Benedict offering a focal point for conservative clerics opposing his move.
This is the latest stage in the Pope’s mission to modernise the Church’s approach to sexuality and render the institution more accepting
It is not surprising that this new stance has been solidified just months after the appointment of a new “head theologian”. In July, the Pope appointed Monsignor Victor Manuel Fernández, the Archbishop of La Plata, as the Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. Msgr Fernández is a progressive, a close ally of the Pope, and this move both elevates him to a position of significant theological authority and perhaps positions him as a potential successor to Francis. Whilst it is Francis that confirms the Church’s change in position, perhaps much of the impetus for the move came from Msgr Fernández.
Whilst this is a huge shift in doctrine, the Church still does not approve of homosexuality. The report was emphatic in emphasising that blessings should not replicate marriage rites, still a sacrament reserved only for heterosexual couples. Furthermore, perhaps to appease conservative outrage, the Pope has allowed individual discretion to be applied; this is not an order to bless same- sex unions, but rather permission to do so if a cleric feels that it does not conflict with his conscience. This is a step towards acceptance, but rife with caveats.
This move also has wide ramifications for secular society. If the Catholic Church, traditionally a symbol of orthodoxy and conservatism, can to some level accept and even bless same-sex unions, then what excuse does secular society have? It partially defeats much of anti-gay marriage conservatives’ arguments if such a symbol of orthodoxy can shift its long-held stance. Jacob Rees-Mogg once defended his opposition to gay marriage with the remark that “I support the teaching of the Catholic church.” Now that the Catholic Church’s teaching supports some level of the blessing of and thus recognition for the validity of same-sex couples, arguments like these become weaker.
This is a step towards acceptance, but rife with caveats
It is true that the Church still regards marriage as the sacramental union between a man and a woman, and so anti-gay marriage activists can still defend their arguments on the premise that the Church does not afford gay couples complete equality. Nonetheless, blessing suggests recognition if not approval, which undermines assertions from religious conservatives of the illegitimacy of same-sex unions. Ironically, those orthodox Catholics most likely to refute same-sex couples are also those that would be most likely to believe in all of the doctrines of the Church, including both Papal Infallibility and Papal Supremacy. If the Pope by definition cannot be wrong, and is the supreme authority on religious matters, Catholics cannot really refute this new policy without contradicting a much older doctrine.
As for gay marriage in religious settings, I am not sure that the Church will ever grant sacramental equality to hetero- and homosexual couples. Nevertheless, the Church’s shift is a powerful step towards acceptance, and the fact that it comes right from the top gives it theological and doctrinal authority that no Catholic fully believing in orthodox Church teaching could refute. The Church’s new stance is a powerful reminder that even the most dogmatic of doctrines can change to reflect new standards of acceptance and equality.
Image: Tris T7 via Wikimedia Commons

