Pierogi to politics: confronting Western ideas of Poland
By Callum Tilley
The Polish dumpling pierogi are perhaps the best thing that you could want for a cold day. Soft, steamed buns, filled with your choice of filling. Most traditionally potato and onion, more recent variants include all manner of sweet and savoury fillings, my particular favourite being chickpea, onion, tomato, and nigella seeds. These tiny little dumplings are heart-warming soul food at its best, and – having consumed my body weight in them over my Christmas holiday in Gdańsk, Poland – I was confused as to why more people in Britain were not publicly lauding them.
A 2015 Buzzfeed article titled ‘British People Try Polish Food For The First Time’ praised pierogi as “the best idea in the world”, with one respondent saying “I want to eat them every day”. However, in response to trying other Polish dishes, the responses were less positive and verged on offensive. When trying Kabanosy (dry-smoked pork sausage), respondents said that was “literally a pepperami”, which it is definitely not. Furthermore, when trying Żurek (rye-flour soup) one respondent said that it was “a proper “make a meal out of everything in your fridge” dish. Got a real week-before-payday feel to it. You’ll eat it, but you can’t wait for better stuff later on.” To me, that is quite an offensive way of saying that you did not like it.
Poland is unfairly misrepresented in British media and public discourse, and this has more damaging consequences than the gatekeeping of pierogi
These responses reflect a prejudiced view of Poland that is not just confined to its cuisine. Broadly misconceived, often deliberately, Poland is unfairly misrepresented in British media and public discourse, and this has more damaging consequences than the gatekeeping of pierogi.
In 2023, a so-called “burgeoning alliance” between Poland and Russia built on perceptions of the Polish government as “one of the most controversial in Europe”, due to conflicts with the EU and restrictive views on progressive social policies. Poland, however, has accepted nearly one million refugees from Ukraine, undermining this (received from history) of Poland as a Russian-aligned state. Furthermore, is true that Poland did enact socially regressive policies, the most notably of which being its anti-LGBT zones. However, due to the EU’s intervention and local court rulings, these were all appealed by the end of 2023.
I am not dismissing the impact of this policy, and others – but I am saying that they did not, and do not, reflect the reality of social relations and acceptance in Poland. In Gdańsk, Poland’s third-largest city, I noticed a large number of LGBT+ couples, and – walking around with my Polish boyfriend – I felt as safe and comfortable as in any large city in Britain. Furthermore, Poland is not the only state to enact concerning policies such as this, yet it seems to receive an unfair assessment that characterises its very existence. If the United States can get away with abortion bans whilst still being a ‘bastion of democracy’, this feels a little hypocritical.
I reject the idea that a single government’s policies should cloud our perceptions of a country. Government policies should not characterise the entirety of our perceptions of Poland, and its rich and vibrant history and culture deserve more respect than to be generalised and coloured with the same brush.
Poland is often highly generalised in Western discourse. Conceived of as Eastern European, many Poles perceive themselves more as European than eastern. Due to territorial shifts, half of modern-day Poland formerly came under German jurisdiction, and so is more architecturally and culturally linked to Western Europe. The eastern half displays clearer cultural links to Eastern Europe, belying its former close cultural and territorial links to what was formerly Imperial Russia. This cultural diversity and plurality goes unrecognised in Western media and public discourse, and the homogenisation of Polish culture is representative of often dismissive views of cultures and histories that the West views to be ‘less than’.
This cultural diversity and plurality goes unrecognised in Western media and public discourse
The October 2023 election saw the Civic Coalition form a government, marking a return to more normative politics. The new Prime Minister, Donald Tusk, has not enacted policies resembling the socially regressive policies of his predecessor from the right-wing Law and Justice Party. Just like many other Western democracies (and unlike some) Poland has returned from the populist right. It is unfair to continue to characterise it as a European cultural and political pariah when, from 20th January 2025, it will have a more progressive government than the United States. Confronting this Western-centric prejudice will allow us to fully appreciate the cultural richesse that Poland, and other Central-Eastern European countries, can show to us.
Going on holiday to Gdańsk over the Christmas holiday, I was expecting snow, but beyond that I did not know what else. Having chosen the city both for its extreme beauty and cultural history (and also the beautifully inexpensive flights) I was looking forward to getting out of the UK and exploring a new country. However, my holiday afforded me more than a break. It opened my eyes to the cultural richness of an extraordinary country. Perhaps more importantly, it presented me with a friendly and welcoming people that made me feel very comfortable – more comfortable as a foreigner in a restaurant ordering in an awkward mix of English and Polish than many British waiters have made me feel ordering in my native language. Despite preconceived ideas about social inclusion (even my own), I felt safer with my boyfriend in Gdańsk than I have in many British cities. The underratedness of pierogi is perhaps symptomatic of British misconceptions of Polish culture, but our broader views of Poland can have more damaging consequences than missing out on delicious steamed dumplings.
Image: Callum Tilley

