America’s Post-Mortem

By Callum Tilley

This was originally meant to be an analysis of how the British treat U.S. politics as a ‘guilty pleasure’. We come together, stay up late, put the T.V. on, grab some snacks; even the Electoral College feels like a points system for some weird house rule in this very important game. Perhaps, I would have argued, it is because we get to feel optimistic every four years. Especially this round – with “joyful” messaging from her campaign – the election cycle felt increasingly optimistic and, indeed, joyful. Instead, sitting here at 10am on Wednesday 6th November, there is very little to be joyous about. As of writing this, Donald Trump is projected to claim the presidency for a second time: the BBC have called 266 Electoral Votes for him, as opposed to Harris’ 219. This is not unprecedented, as Hillary Rodham Clinton would know, but it is still shocking. Americans have elected Trump for a second term, and now we all have to lie in the bed that they have made.

America has made its bed

The consequences of a second Trump term have already been discussed in much detail. He has openly been called a threat to democracy, and the insurrection of 6th January 2021 is all of the evidence we need that he neither respects the very institutions that brought him to power, nor the voice of the American people when it decides to reject him. Trump has called for “revenge” against leading Democrats, including Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi, who he has called “the enemy from within”. This ‘McCarthian’ language is not only reminiscent but a verbatim reproduction of the language that Senator Joseph McCarthy used when purging suspected political and social ‘deviants’ from the American political bureaucracy during the Cold War. Indeed, Trump has called federal employees “crooked people”, and has called for a “cleaning out [of] the Deep State” using an executive order that would set up a system (known as Schedule F) that would allow Trump to fire 50,000 civil servants at will. This politicisation of the bureaucracy is deeply dangerous to the fair functioning of the American state itself.

Trump has been quoted as saying that “Hitler did some good things” by a former Chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and his Project 2025 (now a blueprint for America’s upcoming four years) has been described as a systematic programme for “turning the government into an extension of his personal will”. The consequences extend to the other branches of government. Already at a 6-3 conservative majority, with little oversight and no term limits, the Supreme Court will be shaped by Trump’s second term, and in turn it will shape American politics for years to come. 

Americans have elected Trump for a second term, and now we all have to lie in the bed that they have made

Beyond the institutions, Trump has written in his campaign platform, Agenda47, that “in cities where there has been a complete breakdown of law and order … I will not hesitate to send in federal assets including the national guard until safety is restored”. This is a viable threat against both citizens and his political opponents, as he has threatened to focus on Democratic-run cities. As Levar Stoney, Democratic Mayor of Richmond (VA) has said, “it’s very difficult to autocrat-proof your city”. This is an explicit threat to American civil liberties and freedom; don’t doubt that Trump, projected to win the Presidency, House, and Senate, won’t make the most of his victory to enact his agenda. 

The second Trump presidency will be detrimental to women’s rights. Speaking at a rally on 31st October, Trump said that he would protect women and “do it whether the women like it or not. I’m going to protect them.” He says this would be from “migrants” and “missiles”, but this rhetoric belies his true feelings. Trump, who was recently ordered by a judge to pay $83.3 million to a woman who accused him of sexual assault for defaming her; who has been recorded making sexually explicit sexual assault jokes about “grabbing” women by their genitals; who’s ex-wife swore in her divorce deposition that he raped her; who said that men have to “push back hard” against and “be aggressive” towards #MeToo; who has objectified and insulted female politicians and celebrates; how can anyone believe in his claim to “protect” women? On the morning after the election, arguably the thing we need protecting from the most is Trump himself. 

I do not like this immensely false equivalency – Harris had to be flawless, Trump could be lawless, and he still won the election

Trump is also a threat to women’s healthcare. As per Project 2025, Republicans are considering reviving the 1873 Comstock Act, which outlaws the mailing of abortion-related materials, to ban people from shipping abortion pills. These pills account for about two-thirds of U.S. abortions. But then, it is unlikely that a convicted sex offender would respect women’s reproductive freedoms. Trump is both a threat to women’s freedom in America, and also to the safety of the women around him. The only question is, how could America elect a convicted sex offender – which alone should be enough to disqualify him in people’s minds, if not on the ballot – over a highly experienced former prosecutor, District Attorney, Senator, and Vice-President. The fact that it has not says something about the priorities and values of those that elected him.

It’s the world’s bed too

Due to U.S. geopolitical supremacy, it is not just the U.S. that suffers under Trump. An ally of dictators Putin, Xi Jinping, and Kim Jong Un, the democratic world needs to brace itself for Trump’s foreign policy. The geopolitical situation in the Middle East, already unstable, is bound to worsen with Trump in the White House. In June during the first presidential debate, Trump said President Joe Biden should let Israel “finish the job”, worrying rhetoric about a conflict that is draws humanitarian concern and contradicting increasing calls for a ceasefire. This, along with his policies during his first term – such as moving the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, recognising Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights in Syria, cutting Palestinians out of the Abraham Accords, amongst others – only exacerbate and inflame the situation, especially concerning the tense geopolitical situation with Iran. According to NPR, Israel’s government could seek to “annex the occupied West Bank” if Trump is elected, escalating the conflict even further. Indeed, Trump’s former ambassador to Israel, David Friedman, has advocated that approach. This is not to say that Harris is the answer to the Israel-Palestine conflict, but a second Trump Administration’s foreign policy in the Middle East will, based on his track record and expressed sentiments, no doubt inflame and prolong the conflict and suffering.

On the morning after the election, arguably the thing we need protecting from the most is Trump himself

Ukrainians are another group that did not vote for Trump, yet their lives will indelibly be shaped by his policies. Donald Trump has said that he would end Russia’ war in Ukraine, but any rushed deal will likely leave Kyiv much weaker and European security in even greater peril. This also has implications for NATO, as Trump has repeatedly threatened to withdraw from the alliance, a move that – as Sky News’ Security and Defence Editor has argued – would “sound its death knell”. Whilst his exact approach remains unclear, Trump’s allies have long demanded an end to defence funding being sent to Ukraine. Republican Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene told 60 Minutes that “Ukraine is not the 51st state,“ and that “the United States needs to be pushing for peace in Ukraine, not funding a proxy war with Russia.” Defunding aid would restrict Ukrainian defence strategies, which would lead to a pro-Russia settlement of the war or even a Russian victory. Whilst Taylor Greene represents an extreme, conspiracy theory-heavy view on the right wing of the Republican Party – having previously said that “Jewish space lasers” were the cause of wildfires instead of global warming – her extremely pro-Trump stance means that her views are reflective of the ‘MAGA Republican’ hyper-conservative approach to foreign aid. Ukraine’s war, and European security through NATO, are at risk.

Onwards

Unlike Trump, I respect the institutions of American democracy, to the point where I acknowledge that America as elected a despot that could be the undoing of the very system that brought him to power. So, now that Trump is projected to be sworn in as the 47th President of the United States, what can we – that is, those that woke up this morning, checked the news, and felt a sinking feeling of dread – do to move forwards? 

Firstly, progressive Americans must not lose hope. Due to the 22nd Amendment, Presidents can only sit for two terms. This means that, despite the long-lasting effects of a second Trump Administration, the end is in sight. During that time, and especially before his inauguration, America needs to brace itself. During his last term Trump was more than happy to attack democratic and civic institutions; do not doubt that he will do so again. Democrats also need to regroup and rethink; twice now, two highly qualified candidates (both women, I might add) have lost to Trump. Clinton might have won the popular vote, but (as of today) Harris did not. What went wrong in her campaign? Whilst I do not like this immensely false equivalency – Harris had to be flawless, Trump could be lawless, and he still won the election – the Democrats need to think about how they can win next time. Planning for the midterms, to win back Congress and provide Congressional oversight over the Trump White House, should be the immediate priority. Then eyes need to turn to 2028; no amount of ‘couch gags’ is worth a Vance Presidency. 

Whilst America will not yet have a ‘Madame President’, and the next four years look dark, there is hope

Beyond America, the world (and particularly Europe) needs to come together. European unity in the face of a fluctuating White House needs to support Ukraine and ensure European security. Perhaps the only consolation of a Trump victory is that Europe will – not by choice, but by necessity – need to unify and work together. Whilst a stronger Europe is a small silver lining for a Trump White House, it will perhaps encourage European countries to be less dependent on the U.S. This argument extends to other global conflicts too. European leaders now need to take the lead on bringing about a ceasefire in Israel/Palestine. We cannot wait for America to take the lead in the Middle East – Europe should set its own policy agenda and start diplomatic negotiations with Middle Eastern powers to help create peace in the region. This is not to say that we abandon America – that would be ridiculous – but rather we start to act more independently, and with unity, to bring about peace and security in Ukraine and the Middle East.

Whilst America will not yet have a ‘Madame President’, and the next four years look dark, there is hope. Checks and balances were built into the U.S. system deliberately to manage a despotic President, and Trump’s power, whilst immense, will not be unlimited. His final term will end in 2028/9, and – if they learn from the 2016 and 2024 elections – the Democrats could win the White House. Whilst the populist wave of 2016 is apparently not yet finished in America, the majority democratic governments in Europe now have an opportunity to build a stronger, more unified Europe, take a lead on policy issues, and step away slightly from America’s shadow. Whilst this might feel like looking for the tiny amount of good in a pile of bad, it is something that we can hold on to.

Whilst this might not have been the election of joy, it could – if we want to move forwards – be the election of hope. A Trump White House is a huge threat to American and global security, but it will be finite. It might sound trite to try and find the good in the situation, especially considering the risks, but perhaps we have to. It’s no good wallowing – we need to mourn, rethink, and move onwards; otherwise, we will be stuck in the pit despair. And, if there is one sentiment to take from the Harris campaign into the second Trump Administration, “we are not going back”.

Image: Ramaz Bluashvili via Pexels