Je proteste: the French love for taking to the streets
By Callum Tilley
Since January, France has been engulfed in civil unrest asmprotestors make their oppositionmknown to President Macron’s pension reforms. Buildings have been occupied and set on fire, and infrastructure has been halted by striking workers in support of the protestors. The Government, lacking a majority in the Assemblé Nationale, used Article 49.3 of the Constitution to force through the reforms without a vote on the Bill. This inspired further protest at the undemocratic nature of forcing largely unwanted reforms through without a vote, and an Ifop study found that 78% of people surveyed see the reforms “illegitimate” because of the “unjustified” use of Article 49.3. So, what should we make of these protests? Should we take a leaf out of France’s book? And what do they say about France, and Europe more widely?
Traditionally, France is seen as better at collective action than the UK, and perhaps also readier to riot. This may be a cultural stereotype or even a sign that the French carefully guard what some perceive as their enviable labour rights, but it can also be read as a sign of mass political engagement with a population quick to defend their hard-won rights.
Traditionally, France is seen as better at collective action than the UK.
Perhaps their willingness to strike and protest is a sign that they are more politically engaged and willing to act on their principles. Although these protests have arguably failed – the reforms have been forced through – the protestors have certainly got their message across, and have proven that they won’t accept unwanted interference with their rights without a fight.
This might be seen as reductive, but it is not untrue. Take, for example, the recent passage of the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022, which the human rights group Liberty has said “threatens protest rights”, a fundamental foundation of a democratic system. Can you imagine if the French government had tried to pass a Bill like this? Judging by the reaction to pension
reforms, there would have been mass protests, strikes, and civil disobedience across the country. Yet in the UK there was little protest, and no mass movement to oppose the Bill. Some will say that we should learn something from the French if we want to defend our rights as well as they do.
The recent strikes in the UK are perhaps the beginnings of this change. Public sector workers like teachers, transport workers, doctors, and nurses are taking their issues onto the streets.
The recent strikes in the UK are perhaps the beginnings of this change. Public sector workers like teachers, transport workers, doctors, and nurses are taking their issues onto the streets and making their voices heard. Whether or not you support them, you cannot deny them their fundamental right to strike if you like living in a democracy (although apparently the Health Secretary doesn’t agree; Steve Barclay is taking the Royal College of Nursing to court to try to prevent an upcoming 48 hour strike). Maybe we are, finally, learning from the French model of political engagement and taking our concerns to the streets to make our voices heard.
The French response to pension reforms is taking place in a cost of living crisis (albeit to a different extent), where people fear for their ability to provide for themselves as they near retirement. Aside from the recent strikes, maybe the British public will be inspired to make its voice heard about the discontent over the cost of living crisis, in which people are struggling to heat their homes and buy groceries, with inflation hitting 10.1%. Maybe strikes are the beginning of a movement reminiscent of French uprisings against Macron’s government.
Image: Jeanne Menjoulet via Flickr
