The party of students; will Labour’s new tuition fee policy be enough to keep the student vote?

By Callum Tilley

The Labour Party is typically seen as the party of young people. This is a generalisation, even a stereotype, but it is something which the Party has tried to capitalise on by reaching out to young people and students with its policies. Perhaps its flagship student policy, dating from the Corbyn era, was the promise to abolish tuition fees. An attractive policy for young people, it also drew a stark contrast with the Conservative and Liberal Democrat parties, who tripled tuition fees during their coalition. This commitment has been scrapped by Sir Keir Starmer who, seeking to cut financial commitments during a time of economic uncertainty, has confirmed that he will likely “move on” from the original plans. During his campaign to succeed Jeremy Corbyn as leader, Sir Keir pledged to “support the abolition of tuition fees”, but now, citing “the current economic situation”, he is reneging on his promise in favour of ‘fiscal discipline’.

This is another disappointment for students and young people, many of whom would have seen Labour as a vehicle for change at the next election. Sir Keir has said that he plans to overhaul the “unfair” system as it currently stands, but abandoning the complete abolition of fees could alienate student voters, a key demographic for Labour. What options does the Labour party have? And will they effectively attract the younger vote?

Perhaps Sir Keir and his team are gambling on the fact that young people, disenfranchised with years of Conservative policy that has not been beneficial to them, would vote for Labour anyway.

The Shadow Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, stated that a Labour government “could reduce the monthly repayments for every single graduate” in place of abolishing fees outright. She thinks that reforming the current system, rather than abolishing it “gives scope for a month-on-month tax cut for graduates” which would give them financial “breathing space” as they start their careers. 

This stands in contrast to the Conservatives’ announcement that, for students entering university in 2023, they will start paying off the debt from when they earn £25,000, rather than £27,295, and will pay the debt off for forty years, not thirty. Comparatively, Labour’s offer to reduce payments is certainly more popular than the Conservatives’ plans to increase the cost of a degree. The choice of a less expensive degree with Labour would undoubtedly attract young people and students who otherwise would be worried by the increasing cost of a university education. However, the offer is not as enticing as the former plan to abolish fees altogether.

This might not be a huge electoral risk; perhaps Sir Keir and his team are gambling on the fact that young people, disenfranchised with years of Conservative policy that has not been beneficial to them, would vote for Labour anyway. He knows that the amount of swing and centre votes he would by taking a more ‘fiscally responsible’ position is far greater than the amount he will lose on the left flank by not abolishing tuition fees. Many young people will vote Labour regardless as a perceived lesser ill than the Conservative alternative.

However, if Sir Keir is not careful, he could end up alienating Labour voters further to the left who, put off by rescinded promises and Labour’s drift to the centre, could perhaps vote Green at the next election The Greens’ success in the 2022 local elections proves that they can absorb votes from both parties, which Labour should be aware of if they don’t want to split the left vote. The Greens made huge gains for a third party, gaining 81 seats to bring their total to 156, taking from both Labour and the Conservatives and demonstrating that alienated voters from both parties could choose Green as an alternative. The Green Party’s Co-Leader, Adrian Ramsay, has said that students would pay a “heavy price” because of “the latest U-turn from Keir Starmer’s Labour”. 

The current economic situation is not conducive to  large governmental expenditure, such as shouldering all universities’ running costs with the abolition of fees. However, if he wants to retain the student vote, he will need to keep his promises and deliver the progressive policies that Labour represents. Failing that, alternative policies that address the roots of voter dissatisfaction with the status quo need to be outlined to maintain credibility. 

Image: Jdevereux via Wikimedia Commons