What is the British government’s calculation in attempting to rewrite the Northern Ireland Protocol?

By Caitriona Marsh

The Northern Ireland Protocol was signed and ratified by the British government 18 months ago. It represents a crucial part of the UK’s Withdrawal Agreement with the EU. However, the government’s calls for an audacious rewrite of the arrangement have demonstrated that one of the thorniest issues within Brexit negotiations – the status of Northern Ireland – is far from being resolved.

The signing of the Protocol signified Boris Johnson’s solution to the delicate border issue in Northern Ireland. This introduced an effective border in the Irish Sea, thus avoiding the creation of a hard border on the island of Ireland – a major threat to the 1998 Good Friday Agreement. The Protocol has largely done its job.  With it, Mr Johnson was able to ‘get Brexit done’, achieving what his predecessor Theresa May could not, and effectively avoided a return to contentious checks along the Irish border. While it appears that this move has protected Northern Ireland’s peace process, the question is: at what cost?

The British government is as a result no longer prepared to stand by the Protocol in its current form.

Since the ratification of the Protocol, trade between mainland Britain and Northern Ireland has been severely disrupted, reigniting long-standing and controversial questions about Northern Ireland’s position within the United Kingdom. Despite originally supporting the Protocol and its aims, the Prime Minister now acknowledges that the arrangement is in fact “not working well”. The British government is as a result no longer prepared to stand by the Protocol in its current form.

The Brexit Secretary, Lord Frost, has vocalised concerns about the “rigid implementation” of the EU’s export standards. This is undoubtedly a valid concern. The chairman of Marks & Spencer, Archie Norman, has also warned that, once the appropriate “grace period” ends in September, the retailer will be unable to continue offering its full range of products in Northern Ireland. Thereafter, the full checks required on certain goods, such as cold meats, entering Northern Ireland from mainland Britain will be imposed.

These terms are dictated by the Protocol, but the British government is now asking for a “‘standstill’ on existing arrangements”. This would extend the grace period indefinitely. To Mr Johnson’s critics, this looks like another move by the British government to avoid accepting the arguably foreseeable cost of leaving the EU.

It cannot be denied that the British government is under intense pressure.

It cannot be denied that the British government is under intense pressure. The Protocol is playing a decisive role in the continued precarity of Northern Ireland’s place within the United Kingdom. The British government’s calculation in attempting to rewrite the arrangement is therefore largely a respectable one. It reflects a commitment to support Northern Ireland as an equal and integral part of the UK, while also protecting the Good Friday Agreement.

According to Lord Frost, a renegotiation which would allow goods to enter Northern Ireland from Great Britain more easily is imperative to relieve the practical, social, and political pressures which the Protocol is currently imposing. However, he also asserts that these rewrites are necessary “to put the UK-EU relationship on a stronger, more constructive footing”. 

This statement suggests an attempt to broaden the scope of incentive for the EU beyond the British government’s immediate interests. This, however, begs the question: where was this concern at the signing of the Protocol or indeed during the uncompromising Vote Leave campaign? 

The President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, has stated that the EU will “continue to be creative and flexible within the Protocol framework”, but firmly refuses to renegotiate the agreement.

It remains to be seen whether the EU can be persuaded to commit to such a compromise.

The reasoning for the government’s “necessarily ambitious” proposals is clear and legitimate. Arguably, however, it also reflects a certain arrogance on the side of the British government. Lord Frost proclaims that the “ball is now in the EU’s court”. Meanwhile, the government dangles the threat of the Protocol’s article 16 – this enables either party to take “unilateral action if the implementation of the agreement gives rise to negative consequences”. In fact, the British government is in desperate need of European charity.

It remains to be seen whether the EU can be persuaded to commit to such a compromise. What is clear is that Northern Ireland – who voted to remain – is now regrettably relying on EU sympathy to guarantee practical and political stability. Meanwhile, the British government criticises an agreement that it negotiated and signed itself in 2019.

Image: felibrilu via Flickr