OceanGate discourse: pertinent or distasteful?

By Caitriona Marsh

The loss of the OceanGate Titan submersible has provoked lively, widespread debate online – from the moment it went missing to the public disclosure of the implosion which resulted in the instant death of all five passengers. It was not simply the tragic loss of life that garnered such attention. The fact that guests on board each paid $250,000 to experience a reportedly unparalleled view of the Titanic wreck has led to a global reaction that is both understandable and quite problematic. The reaction, fuelled by jokes and political satire, is now dividing public opinion, with many critical of posts they regard as lacking in empathy and in poor taste.

There are, however, logical reasons for such a reaction. Firstly, the five passengers who boarded the Titan are not representative of the general population. They were millionaires and billionaires who made a costly purchase – and one which, according to Ben Taub’s extended piece in the New Yorker, was overhasty and riddled with warnings. It is therefore unsurprising that the general public are struggling to empathise with the loss faced by the families of those on board.

The aspirations of the excessively wealthy, combined with social media use, lead to societal divides and alienation

Secondly, the nature of our social media societies means that we are distanced from the words that we write and the people to whom they are addressed. Today, the scale of online hate demonstrates that social media spaces allow people to behave differently to how they would in real life. Trends gain momentum and each individual post becomes just another face in the crowd, thus softening the perceived impact for its author.

Thirdly and finally, this kind of dark humour is by no means a new concept. Among Generation Z in particular, many refer to it as a coping mechanism: a behaviour developed in order to combat the (increasing) absurdity of the modern world. The aspirations of the excessively wealthy, combined with social media use, lead to societal divides and alienation. Taking these elements into account, the use of jokes and political satire to react to the loss of the Titan submersible becomes somewhat less striking.

This reaction may be understandable, but does that make it justified? Aside from the political questions which have arisen in the aftermath of the implosion, four families have suffered a loss in extremely distressing circumstances. It could of course be argued that those who put themselves on board the submersible inevitably opened themselves up to such a reaction. However, perhaps the use of jokes and political satire in this scenario can only really be justified if they provoke meaningful and productive discussion.

Perhaps the use of jokes and political satire in this scenario can only really be justified if they provoke meaningful and productive discussion

In the same week that the submersible began its descent, a fishing boat, overloaded with refugees and attempting to cross from Libya to Italy, sank off the coast of Greece. At least 78 people have been found dead with hundreds of others missing. After signalling for help, the boat is reported to have been stationary for at least seven hours before it capsized. The Greek Coast Guard maintains that there was no immediate danger before this point. In contrast, the cost of the international search led by the US Coast Guard and Navy to find the missing submersible is estimated to lie in the millions. Unfortunately, very little of the political discourse sparked by the implosion of the Titan submersible has focused on the ironic timing of these two disasters and the disparity between their respective responses. The scale of recent online mockery may indeed have further trivialised the Icarian ambitions of the ultra-wealthy.

The nature of political satire, even in the event of personal tragedy, may ultimately be a question of taste. As Ricky Gervais put it: “Everyone has the right to be offended. Everyone has the right to offend. But no one has the right to never be offended.” In any case, the implosion of the Titan submersible will hopefully act as a warning sign. Although technology is increasingly offering us the possibility of a limitless existence, the value – or perhaps necessity – of imposing limits on ourselves should never be ignored.

Image credit: Oceangate Expeditions via AP