Scotland’s Drug Decriminalisation Proposals: Nonsensical and Noncommittal

By Maddy Chammings

The Minister for Drugs and Alcohol Policy of Scotland, Elena Whitham, has announced the Scottish Government’s intention to decriminalise the possession of drugs for personal use, alongside plans to create centres for controlled consumption. The government justifies this with the idea of easing the treatment of addicts and reducing deaths. However, the U.K government has blocked these plans as drug policy is not a devolved matter. Scotland has the worst figures in Europe when it comes to drug-related deaths, so the government’s eagerness to face this is expected. However, the question remains: would this policy actually help with the treatment of drug abusers and would the complete legalisation of drugs actually help alleviate drug-related issues?

Would these [drug consumption] centres actually encourage treatment, or act as a means of enabling addiction?

Firstly, this policy proposed by the Scottish Government does not completely legalise drugs. The policy only decriminalises the consumption of drugs, with the intention of reducing the stigma associated with addiction and encouraging abusers to seek support by visiting ‘drug consumption rooms,’ where they would be able to satisfy their addiction in a controlled environment. Inevitably, this will lower the overdose death rate and may encourage those already seeking treatment to continue. However, questions can be raised over the practicality of such facilities: Would they actually be used? Is it right that they should be government-funded, paid for by the taxpayer? Would these centres actually encourage treatment, or act as a means of enabling addiction? In spite of these questions, it should be said that Overdose Prevention Centres have worked in reducing the death rate in the U.S. However, whether this has reduced the rate of those abusing drugs is unclear. This shows that overall, the decriminalisation of the consumption of drugs does not necessarily guarantee treatment, and leaves questions unanswered on how drug facilities would result in a society where drug-related problems are eliminated.

Another key point to raise about this Scottish government proposal is one related to the supply of drugs. By decriminalising possession for consumption and not for supply, the government would only encourage drug dealers to operate on a larger scale, and would likely increase the number of drug consumers due to a lack of legal deterrent on personal use. This would mean that associated issues- gang violence and exploitation- would not be dealt with, and may even intensify if demand increases. This means that the government should legalise the supply of drugs alongside possession or take control of supply themselves if it wants to defeat such criminal activity. The Evening Standard does mention how Whitham would consider implementing ‘the regulated supply of drugs’. As mentioned, this would deal with the criminal aspect of the drug problem, but of course, the ethics and practicality of government supplying drugs, especially Class A, is controversial.

Finally, my main point of contention with this policy is that it does not seek to reduce the issues that often accompany addiction, such as theft, domestic abuse, child neglect, unemployment and poverty. The decriminalisation of consumption would likely make it a more difficult feat for those addicted to ditch their drugs and would only cause such social issues to worsen. A similar case would be the legality and ensuing normalisation of alcohol consumption and the subsequent issues associated with alcoholism. Surely the legal consumption of drugs would lead to a similar outcome?

The policy proposed by the Scottish government is nonsensical as it is a noncommittal halfway point between criminalisation and legalisation, and leaves unanswered many questions on how the policy proposed would treat addiction

To conclude, the only way forward to greatly reduce drug-related issues as a whole would be to either continue with the complete criminalisation of certain drugs or do the opposite and completely legalise their sale and consumption. This is a view that should be favoured for softer drugs like cannabis, as it would widen the capacity of help for those addicted, as is the case with alcohol, and force the criminal gangs that sell these drugs into redundancy. The policy proposed by the Scottish government is nonsensical as it is a noncommittal halfway point between criminalisation and legalisation, and leaves unanswered many questions on how the policy proposed would treat addiction. This leaves the ultimate conclusion that the proposed policy is nothing but an attempt to stick a plaster over the drug epidemic and solely focus on lowering the number of deaths in time for the next general election, without actually seeking to deal with the wider issues associated with addiction that plague Scottish society.

Image credit: gov.scot via Flickr