Television reboots: do they right the wrongs of their original counterparts?

By Caitriona Marsh

For decades, the entertainment industry has strongly favoured the remake. In the case of films, many have followed their originals closely. Today, trendy television reboots of series such as Gossip Girl, recently released on BBC iPlayer, seem to be making a more striking statement. Noteworthy cast changes and new dialogues about race, gender and sexuality accompany the original format and thus highlight the issue of representation in mainstream television. Is this a legitimate way to remedy the former lack of on-screen diversity, or are the changes merely performative?

The act of reusing material in entertainment is by no means a new concept. In the seventeenth century songs were sold and bought on sheet music as a central part of popular culture. New sets of lyrics were repeatedly applied to well-known tunes as a way of boosting sales. We can compare this to pop singers choosing to cover songs or embedding recognisable melodies within their music. 

Society today encourages incessant progress, and we tend to believe that total originality in art and entertainment is what we crave. However, everything we consume is inevitably charged with what has come before. Our brains enjoy picking up on familiar information within the new. Even Lin Manuel-Miranda’s Hamilton, which has been lauded for its total originality of form, is bursting with literary and musical references to Drake, Shakespeare and even the Bible. This is arguably what makes it so captivating.  Recycling tunes, lyrics, storylines and characters stimulate nostalgia. This is and has always been a natural way to engage an audience.

There will always be the suspicion that fuller representation serves as a fig-leaf to obscure the real motive, the pursuit of profit.  

Reboots which appeal to our sense of nostalgia, but feature diverse casts and topical issues, offer a potentially exciting way to combine modern entertainment and activism. However, relying on these additions alone is less admirable. Slotting actors who fit the diversity quota of the twenty-first century into uninspiring scripts and productions points to performative intentions, with an underlying economic agenda.

HBO’s Gossip Girl is a sequel to the shamelessly outrageous original series which ran from 2009 to 2012.  It showcases two black women in its lead roles with an array of sexually fluid characters and as such marks a clear break from the heavily homogenous main characters of the original. The reboot, however, lacks the allure of its predecessor. The clique of uber-rich Manhattan teens now oscillates awkwardly between unapologetic ruthlessness, a crucial aspect of the original, and a newfound earnestness that attempts to capture the essence of the woke teenager. Something, unfortunately, just doesn’t add up.

Rebooting popular television series can be a legitimate way of amending unbalanced representation in mainstream television. These reboots should, however, be able to stand up on their own. Otherwise, there will always be the suspicion that fuller representation serves as a fig-leaf to obscure the real motive, the pursuit of profit.  

This does not take away from the potential wider value of these projects. By appealing to the audience’s craving for comforting familiarity and simultaneously introducing casts that reflect the diverse reality of our communities, producers have an opportunity to make a powerful impact. Instead of effacing the art which centred only on society’s privileged groups, reboots could prove to be an interesting way to recognise progress and facilitate honest dialogues surrounding racial, social and political injustice.

Even cynical motives may lead to the normalising of more balanced representation so that it becomes first accepted, and then expected.

While Gossip Girl may have fallen short of greatness, the notion of the trendy reboot is more nuanced than it may first appear. It has the ability to draw attention to valuable aspects of previous TV successes, whilst incorporating the changing views of society and perhaps pushing us towards more inclusive and thoughtful behaviours.  

Whether performative or not, increasing representation in mainstream television at least shows that producers are listening to society’s wider concerns. Moreover, even cynical motives may lead to the normalising of more balanced representation so that it becomes first accepted, and then expected. This will work more effectively, however, if the rebooted products are of high artistic quality.

Image: Gotham via Getty Images