West Indies cricket facing a downward spiral

By Tom Ewart Smith

Only six hours prior to writing this article, BBC Sport notified me of “another dominant performance” by England Women, who took a 2-0 lead over the West Indies in their T20 series. This display adds to the downward spiral of the ‘Windies’ on the international cricketing stage, not only for the Men, but also for the Women’s team.

While they did have major success in 2016, with the Men’s side winning the T20 World Cup, they haven’t reached anywhere near this height over the past few years. One simply has to just list their results over the past year to notice a worrying situation.

The Men’s team have lost in several ODI series — to New Zealand, India, Bangladesh and Pakistan — and has had little success in the T20 format. Most notably, they crashed out of the T20 World Cup in October, not even making it to the Super12 stage. Meanwhile, the likes of Zimbabwe, the Netherlands, and Ireland surpassed them – all three of these countries being lower in the T20 rankings than the Windies.

They also recently lost to Australia in a Test Match series, 2-0. More importantly, it was the way in which they lost that highlighted their weak position. Australia comfortably won the first match by 164 runs and then proceeded to humiliate their visitors with a 419-run victory.

The situation for the Women’s team isn’t much better, considering their recent form. In this month alone, England has won five straight matches across ODIs and T20s against the Windies Women. Earlier in the year, New Zealand women beat them in the same two formats.

Usually when cricketing nations see a dip in form, it is within one or two formats, while being able to maintain success in the other formats. This isn’t the case for the West Indies — one can identify a lack of success across all three cricketing formats.

It is also important to note that the victories they have notched up haven’t been of great significance. While they did beat England 1-0 in a three-match Test series back in March, this was before the Three Lions had adopted their much more dynamic and successful approach to the game — helped by a change in captaincy and coaching.

The West Indies selectors have made some poor decisions which have arguably cost them

They also beat Bangladesh in a Test series in June, but as their opponents have been placed 9th out of 10 in the Test rankings this can again be seen as an insignificant win. The same can be said for their ODI series win against the Netherlands.

Therefore, having examined their losses and the significance of their wins, one must ask why this collection of Caribbean islands has experienced a downward spiral on the international cricketing stage.

Andre Russell — one of the West Indies’ great cricketers in recent times and a T20 genius – provides an explanation. In a recent interview with Gulf News, he claimed that Windies cricket is going backwards “because they are not picking the best, forcing good and active players to retire because of the system”.

This must be taken with a pinch of salt as he is certainly referring to himself, having not been picked for the T20 World Cup in October. Therefore, there is a layer of bias and disdain to his comments. However, his point is still valid – the West Indies selectors have made some poor decisions which have arguably cost them.

Russell, Sunil Narine and Shimron Hetmyer were all big names who missed out in October and who are experienced T20 players. This meant the Windies Men lacked know-how and expertise in crucial moments during the World Cup. Russell mentions in the interview that he has played over 400 T20 matches throughout his career and as he rightly points out: “that’s a lot of experience”. A lack of senior members arguably cost the team.

Another contributing factor is a lack of experience on foreign surfaces. The West Indies have proven they can succeed at home, but when it comes to playing in Australia, for example, they have had little success. If they want to compete for big trophies, they will have to improve on different surfaces to what they are used to.

Why does it matter? A lack of sustained success in Test cricket for the Windies could arguably have consequences for the sport. Poor results may contribute to Test cricket dying out in the Caribbean and the absence of such a historically giant cricketing team could be devastating in the wider picture. Furthermore, the shorter formats are still extremely popular in the Windies, despite international results. And so, this may further result in the Windies pulling the plug on Test cricket.  

Image: It’s no game via Flickr