England’s ODI struggles: where did it all go wrong?
By Tom Ewart Smith
England’s recent One-Day International (ODI) cricket struggles, capped by a series defeat to the West Indies, have raised tough questions about the team’s current state and the priorities of the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB). It’s a sharp fall from the heights of 2019, when England, once known for a cautious approach, revolutionised the 50-over game with aggressive, fearless cricket and captured their first World Cup title. As England struggles to reclaim its form, fans and analysts alike are asking what’s gone wrong – and what role the ECB and current leadership need to play in turning things around.
At the heart of England’s decline is inconsistency in selection. Since Eoin Morgan stepped down, Jos Buttler has taken over the captaincy, but he’s yet to establish the sense of stability and purpose that defined Morgan’s tenure. Buttler’s prowess as a batsman and wicketkeeper is undisputed, but he faces the challenge of unifying an unsettled team.
Five years ago, England’s squad was built around a core of reliable players who were highly specialised in the ODI format. However, that core has splintered, with Joe Root, one of England’s most dependable ODI batsmen, seeing limited opportunities in recent fixtures due to other format commitments. Root, known for his consistency and ability to anchor innings, has been a glaring absence in key matches, leaving a void that more inexperienced players have struggled to fill. The negative effect of a heavily packed England cricket schedule on the ODI team has been demonstrated over the past month. The Test tour of Pakistan has resulted in the absence of key 50-over players, such as the aforementioned Root, along with the likes of Harry Brook, Ben Duckett and Jamie Smith. All four of them provide crucial stability to the batting lineup but only the Test team has been afforded such privilege.Â
Meanwhile, England’s bowling unit has shown signs of fatigue and lack of depth, struggling to execute in the crucial middle and death overs. Without a clear plan for building around experienced players like Chris Woakes and Adil Rashid or developing new talents who can deliver in these roles, England’s bowling has looked increasingly vulnerable under pressure.
For England to regain their footing, the ECB must re-evaluate their approach to the 50-over game, beginning with creating a more consistent core squad.
A major contributing factor has been the ECB’s shift in focus toward T20 cricket, especially with the creation of The Hundred – a shorter, 100-ball format launched to attract new fans. With English players prioritising T20 leagues both domestically and internationally, the 50-over game has often taken a back seat. The ECB’s prioritisation of formats outside traditional ODI cricket has limited the time and resources invested in developing a strong, cohesive ODI side. As players like Phil Salt and Sam Curran frequently toggle between formats, they find it difficult to adapt to the different demands of ODIs, where patience and consistency are more crucial than the fast-paced flair of T20.
For England to regain their footing, the ECB must re-evaluate their approach to the 50-over game, beginning with creating a more consistent core squad. Mark Wood, for example, has proven his ability as a strike bowler but is often rested due to his commitments across all formats, making it difficult to establish rhythm in ODIs. England’s ODI setup would benefit greatly from keeping players like Wood and Rashid dedicated to the format, allowing the team to develop partnerships and synergy on the field. Consistency in selection, with a balanced mix of seasoned players and emerging talents, could restore the team’s confidence and performance.
The ECB also needs to address its focus on T20 and The Hundred, ensuring that England’s best ODI players aren’t lost to other formats. Former World Cup-winning coach Trevor Bayliss prioritised creating a cohesive ODI side, which ultimately led to their success. As the unsuccessful Matthew Mott departs and Brendon McCullum takes control of all three international formats in January, I have no doubt that the same amount of energy injected by Bayliss will be done by the Kiwi. The appointment of the New Zealand cricketing legend as both the Test and white-ball coach for the Three Lions is, in my opinion, a wise choice.
Leadership will play a defining role in whether England can revive their ODI fortunes. McCullum and leadership go hand-in-hand. While Buttler is respected as a player, he’s yet to fully assert himself as an ODI leader in the way Morgan did. But perhaps the new head coach can provide the invaluable support that Buttler needs to win big. He will be hoping to build as positive a relationship with the New Zealander as Stokes has with the Test side.
Ultimately, England’s road back to the top will require a unified focus from the ECB, players, and management. The team’s recent struggles should serve as a wake-up call for the ECB to prioritise the ODI format seriously. And while the recent results have been worrying, I am confident that Buttler and McCullum can lead the side to a new era of success. The road to redemption begins soon, in February of next year, as Pakistan host the ICC Champions Trophy. In just a few months we shall see if faith from fans such as myself is rewarded.Â
Image: Yorkspotter via Wikimedia Commons

