How will Lineker’s likely replacements fare on Match of the Day?
By Tom Ewart Smith
Gary Lineker’s departure as the flagship host of Match of the Day (MOTD) was announced over a month ago, in mid-November. Following an illustrious professional football career – including stints with top English clubs, success at Barcelona, and a pivotal role for England from 1984 to 1992 – Lineker seamlessly transitioned into the world of football broadcasting.
He began hosting MOTD in 1999, and his 25-year tenure as the show’s host will conclude in May 2025. While Lineker will continue to present the BBC’s FA Cup coverage and remain a familiar face during the 2026 World Cup, he plans to step back from live presenting for the BBC after that tournament.
At first glance, his departure might seem like a minor footnote in the sporting world. However, broadcasting and presenting play a critical role in shaping the viewer’s experience of watching sports. This is especially true for football, where expert analysis and engaging hosting significantly enhance the enjoyment for fans.
Lineker’s light-hearted, relaxed approach has been central to the charm of MOTD, whether it’s through the flagship highlights show on a Saturday evening or live game coverage. His departure raises an important question for fans: who can fill the void left by such an iconic presenter? It’s a pertinent issue for a show that attracted 33 million viewers last season.
While no official announcement has been made, multiple media outlets have reported that Lineker’s role will be shared among three hosts
While no official announcement has been made, multiple media outlets have reported that Lineker’s role will be shared among three hosts: Kelly Cates, Mark Chapman, and Gabby Logan. They are expected to rotate hosting duties for MOTD and MOTD2, the Sunday highlights show. However, this rumoured lineup has sparked some online backlash, with critics decrying the inclusion of two female hosts as “woke nonsense” and calling for a single presenter to maintain stability. Yet such negativity seems misplaced when considering the trio’s credentials and track records.
All three presenters bring extensive experience within the BBC, giving them a strong grasp of the corporation’s culture and expectations. In an era of heightened scrutiny over public comments, their familiarity with the BBC’s environment reduces the likelihood of on-air missteps.
Kelly Cates is no stranger to high-pressure broadcasting environments. As a regular host for Sky Sports’ football coverage alongside pundits Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher, she has earned widespread praise for her polished, professional delivery. Given that Sky is Europe’s largest media company and pay-TV broadcaster by revenue, transitioning to the BBC should pose little challenge for Cates. Her smooth and assured approach to presenting makes her a natural fit for MOTD.
Mark Chapman is arguably the ideal successor for MOTD
Mark Chapman is arguably the ideal successor for MOTD. Since 2013, he has hosted MOTD2 and has been a trusted face for some of the BBC’s most prestigious sports programs, such as Sports Report on BBC 5 Live, the world’s longest-running sports radio show. Chapman’s easy rapport with guests and his thoughtful, inquisitive style are reminiscent of Lineker’s approach. At 51, his enduring curiosity and passion for the game ensure he remains relatable and engaging. His knack for probing questions and insightful discussions will resonate with viewers seeking a deeper understanding of football.
Gabby Logan, a Durham University alumna, is one of the most respected voices in British sports broadcasting. Her prominence in the industry is underscored by her role as Amazon Prime’s lead football presenter. Additionally, she co-hosts The Sports Agents podcast with Chapman, showcasing their strong on-air chemistry. Logan’s distinguished career and versatility ensure she is more than capable of stepping into Lineker’s shoes. Her collaboration with Chapman and Cates will help maintain a cohesive presenting style, minimizing disruptions for viewers.
Cates, Chapman, and Logan’s intertwined careers further bolster their suitability as a team. Cates frequently hosts 5 Live Sport, a midweek sports show on BBC Radio where Chapman is a regular contributor. This familiarity among the trio will translate into a seamless dynamic on MOTD, preserving the show’s legacy and appeal.
Despite initial scepticism, the combined expertise and rapport of Cates, Chapman, and Logan have the potential to uphold and even enhance the high standards set by Lineker. As the torch is passed to this accomplished trio, football fans can look forward to a fresh, yet familiar MOTD experience that continues to celebrate the beautiful game.
Image: LEEDS 2023 via Wikimedia Commons

