Noa-Lynn Van Leuven and the tightrope of transgender inclusivity

By Joseph Saunders

In the first round of the PDC World Darts Championship, Kevin Doets beat Noa-Lynn Van Leuven 3-1. As a match between the world number 51 and 144, very little attention would have been paid to the match apart from in the Netherlands, where both players are from. That is, were it not for the fact Van Leuven is transgender.

Van Leuven’s rise has been rapid – 2022 was her first year on the PDC tour as she passed stringent tests in order the qualify for the women’s tour. Fast forward two years and she qualified for the Grand Slam of Darts thanks to her second position in the women’s Order of Merit, darts’ answer to traditional world rankings.

As the first trans woman to play at Alexandra Palace, it was here where Van Leuven captured global attention. And in the current climate as a transgender athlete, that means plenty of abuse. Boos echoed around Ally Pally as she was eliminated from a tough group that contained Michael Van Gerwen and Gary Anderson, both multiple time finalists in the competition.

At these 2025 World Championships however, Van Leuven seemingly faced little to no abuse from the crowd. As the Guardian’s Jonathan Liew noted on a few boos, “this was no act of protest, or prejudice, or cruelty. Van Leuven was simply paying the public penalty that awaits all players when they start a leg with two 180s and then miss the seventh dart of an attempted nine-dart finish.”

Daily death threats on various social media platforms are met with despairing indifference by these huge corporations

What Van Leuven has had to contend with is online abuse. Daily death threats on various social media platforms are met with despairing indifference by these huge corporations. One particularly guilty party is X (formerly known as Twitter – yawn). Everyone knows what a splendidly wonderful job Elon Musk has done since he took over the platform. So much so in fact that the Professional Darts Corporation’s official account had to disable comments on any videos featuring Van Leuven, as moderators were seemingly incapable of taking down the hoards of death threats and misinformation.

It is an interesting distinction to note where transgender hatred in sport comes from. Van Leuven was the victim of a huge amount of abuse following her victory in a women’s series event in summer 2024. Palatinate’s ex sport editor George Simms wrote a piece about the Dutchwomen’s experience for the i and was predictably faced with an enormous amount of hatred online. This seems to come from two separate places. There are those who are outrightly transphobic and there are those who wish to protect women’s sport from what is perceived as a threat. I would like to think anyone reading this article would disregard the first option as morally corrupt, but the second has plenty of nuance.

The primary threat attributed to trans women’s inclusion in women’s sport is an exploitation of physical advantage over cis-female competitors. While this is clearly true in many sports such as swimming or football, is it in darts?

The primary threat attributed to trans women’s inclusion in women’s sport is an exploitation of physical advantage over cis-female competitors

A 2002 paper from the University of Middlesex set out the ‘Gender differences in target throwing skills and dart playing performance in elite dart players.’ Their findings conclusively pointed to male superiority in target throwing and significantly higher dart averages. Which begs the question, if men are better darts players, why does the PDC deem it appropriate to host mixed competitions such as the World Championships? No woman has ever got close to winning the prize – trailblazer Fallon Sherrock came the closest with a last 32 exit in 2021.

To answer that question, we have to look further afield. Other elite sports are somewhat successfully gender integrated, such as equestrian. Whilst events such as dressage and show jumping are approximately evenly split between male and female competitors, flat racing is dominated by male jockeys.

Other sports have failed to generate elite talent in mixed competitions. Snooker has seen only four women on the main tour and Formula One has delayed and delayed the chances of talented female drivers; motorsport overall has been criticised for its handling of women’s divisions, as many believe they should focus on nurturing female talent in mixed events. Another target sport, shooting, was gender integrated from 1968-1980 at the Olympics.

With these examples in mind, darts has a lower gender performance disparity than almost any sport above, rendering it perhaps the most appropriate sport for gender integration. The only major obstacle remaining is cis women’s ability to feel comfortable playing against trans women. Is it really necessary to deride a transgender women at a women’s only darts tournament?

It is those who know the least about the sport that appear to be the most vociferous in their resistance to trans inclusion

A fascinating tell is where the criticism is coming from. Sherrock and reigning world champion Luke Humphries have backed Van Leuven, as have many other huge names in the sport. If her direct competitors are comfortable with her inclusion, and her physiological benefit is negligible enough that the PDC can put on a gender inclusive World Darts Championship, many would argue the outright hatred that was on display this summer was unneccesary. It is those who know the least about the sport that appear to be the most vociferous in their resistance to trans inclusion.

Van Leuven’s hope is that 2025 will see her progress to the PDC Pro Tour, potentially leaving the less lucrative Women’s Series behind. Should she fail, there is the possibility of the transgender debate flaring up again. The extent to which it has raged so far is an embarrassing glimpse into how little humanity people show to vulnerable minorities.

Whatever her future holds, her defiance in the face of such anger reveals a steely character. Noa-Lynn Van Leuven should be praised whenever she steps up to the oche.

Image: DARTS NOW via Wikimedia Commons