Durham cosmologists solve the mystery of Milky Way’s satellite galaxies
Born too late to explore the Earth, born too early to explore space, born just in time to observe a bizarre thin rotating disk of satellite galaxies orbiting the Milky Way. This strange cosmic artefact – known as the ‘plane of satellites’ – has challenged traditional conceptions of cosmology for over 50 years, but according to new research the fact that we see it is nothing more than a massive fluke.
According to the standard cosmological model, the ΛCDM model, the galaxies of today formed in clumps of cold dark matter, called dark matter ‘halos’. Despite the name, these halos tend to be flattened, elongated round shapes – ellipsoids – rather than flat rings.
Given there is no known mechanism to form rotating satellite planes in the region of the dark matter halo surrounding the galaxy, it was thought that the Milky Way’s satellite galaxies should be distributed more roundly – mimicking the distribution of dark matter.
Therefore, the plane of satellites, which is not only flat but seems to consist of coherently orbiting galaxies, was thought for decades to be at odds with the standard cosmological model.
They found that while we now saw an unusual plane arrangement, within a few hundred million years the illusion would vanish
However, new simulations combined with the latest data from the European Space Agency’s GAIA space observatory, the result of a collaboration between Durham and Helsinki Universities, have shown that the strange alignment of galaxies is just a cosmological coincidence which will dissipate in time. “A matter of being in the right place at the right time,” as Durham’s Professor Carlos Frenk, study co-author, puts it.
Using precise GAIA motion measurements for the 11 satellite galaxies allowed researchers to perform orbital integration to predict how their distribution would vary into the future and back into the past.
They found that while we now saw an unusual plane arrangement, within a few hundred million years (in cosmological terms, a mere moment) the illusion would vanish. We’ll instead see a rounder distribution more in line with what the standard cosmological model would typically predict.
In particular, the temporary conjunction of Leo I and Leo II, the two most distant satellites – dwarf galaxies in the constellation Leo – has an outsized effect on the observed flatness of the ‘plane’. However, both these galaxies are currently crossing the supposed cosmic ‘plane’.
“We have been able to remove one of the main outstanding challenges to the cold dark matter theory.”
Professor carlos frenk
The research also showed that the flatness of the plane of satellites is much more common than previously reported. Earlier work which showed only 0.7% of standard cosmological model simulations produced a system as flat as the Milky Way was found to fail to correct for the effects of artificial disruption, an artefact of simulation inaccuracies.
The problem was a particularly thorny issue for dark matter models of the universe. Unlike other discrepancies between predictions and observations of Milky Way satellite galaxies that can be explained away by other means, including alternative forms of dark matter particles, there was no such explanation of the plane of satellites.
Hence, the work overcomes a large hurdle for the ΛCDM model, and other dark matter cosmological models. Prof Frenk spoke to Palatinate earlier this year about how he was “still trying to rule out cold dark matter” models of the Universe after 40 years of trying. It looks like he’s got his work cut out for him.
“We have been able to remove one of the main outstanding challenges to the cold dark matter theory. It continues to provide a remarkably faithful description of the evolution of our Universe,” explains Professor Frenk. The findings have been published in the journal Nature Astronomy.
Image: Till Sawala / Sibelius collaboration under CC-BY license

