We cannot let words on Iraq cloud our actions in Syria

by David Wynne-Griffith

 

With history appearing before our very eyes in the Middle East, it seems to be a good time to reflect upon the sanctity of the divisive idea of liberal interventionism.

Forged in the first Gulf War, chrystillized in the NATO bombing campaign in Kosovo and humiliated in the streets of Mogadishu and Baghdad, it is undoubtedly the defining moral dilemma of our time.

State sovereignty or individual security, moralistic intervention or nihilistic interference, human rights preservation or conflict exacerbation- it is an idea that cuts hard political lines across the international community and one that confronts us once more in the bloody streets of Babr-Ama.

Just as in Libya, we are seeing a desperate despot wrangling to preserve his own power, and in the end, his own life. The chilling, yet calm odour of Bachar Al-Assad is certainly a change from the moronic meglomania of Muhammur Gaddafi.

But underneath this political veneer, they derive the same monstrous and uncompromising intent.

As it should be plainly evident by now, the Syrian leader will stop at nothing to preserve his iron grip over his country despite farcical attempts to embrace popular referendums and democratic reforms. So, the world is once again calling for action, for ‘something to be done’, even if that something involves intervening without due process in the affairs of a sovereign state.

However, despite the daily reports of unrelenting atrocities in Homs and the mounting civilian death toll which includes the deaths of Marie Colvin, a war correspondent for the Sunday Times and Remi Ochlick, an award-winning French photographer, the dove arguments against Western engagement in Syria stack up.

The Assad regime may be waging a thuggish war against the upstanding resistance, but it’s intentions are more subtle than it’s insane excuses.

Assad intends to slowly twist the sectarian knife that cuts through Syrian civil society and to turn his own minority Allawite, Christian and Shia minorities against the underpowered Sunni majority, unleashing a catastrophic civil war.

As Hillary Clinton has constantly pointed out, clumsy Western intervention could hasten this prospect and with the UN Security Council anaesthetised by Russia and China, the potential of a nasty re-run of the Great Power blocks f the Great War, with Russia, China, Iran and Hezbollah pitted against the West, is entering the realm of the possible.

The argument goes that intervention could trigger even more sickening chaos than is already present. Meanwhile, the hawks bark moral imperatives without sane solutions, while the doves hark back to tails of misery and sectarian strife in Iraq.

Both sides are looking beyond immediate palliatives that could be put in place to ensure the safety of civilians that currently, have nothing but bombs raining down upon their innocent heads.

The reality of the war in Iraq was right intention, wrong timing. But it’s timeless precedent is the war’s true legacy.

It has hamstrung the intentional community, scrambled the Western world’s moral compass and endowed the self-interest of realpolitik with a fat bargaining chip.

But we cannot let the mistakes of Iraq mar our action in Syria.

The arguments against intervention in Syria are undoubtedly numerous, prescient and profound, but we have past the point of diminishing returns on inaction.

Commentators and politicians call for caution to avoid a civil war, but to all intents and purposes, that is exactly what the conflict is turning into either way. It is simultaneously the callous goal of the perpetrators and the only way out of the carnage.

But it is a hopelessly uneven fight, as the Assad regime undoubtedly receives weaponry through an increasingly porous Northern border with Turkey, the Free Syrian Army cannot hope to put up any kind of notable resistance.

We must learn the nature of the beast that we face. Despots in turmoil, especially overtly fascist ones, have no bargaining price, no wilful compromise and as we must be learning, no mercy.

The Western world is afraid to take sides, lest we land on the wrong side of the volatile Middle Eastern dice once again, but we have a side. We must not let political short-termism blind us, there is a lot that can be done short of storming in with full-scale military intervention.

Despite the substantial ills that may lie ahead, for the people of the Middle East, the hat is over the wall. They just need to find strength to jump over the wall and grab the prize. But to do this they need that imperative leg-up.

At the moment, they are floundering in the dirt at the bottom of the wall while we decide to make up our minds.