Who guards the guardians?
by Dominic Daly
It has been nearly eight months since David Cameron announced there would be an inquiry into the culture, practices and ethics of the British press. This followed allegations that News of the World had told employees to hack into phones of celebrities and members of the public who were currently in the media spotlight, with cases such the hacking of the phones of the murdered schoolgirl Milly Dowler and victims of the 7/7 bombing being highlighted.
On 13 July 2011, Cameron announced that Lord Justice Leveson would lead the Inquiry with a body of 6 advisors.
Leveson opened the Inquiry on 14 November 2011 stating, “The press provides an essential check on all aspects of public life.”
That is why any failure within the media affects all of us. At the heart of this Inquiry, therefore, may be one simple question: who guards the guardians?”
The Inquiry aims to look into the matter of the phone hacking scandal with a view to “make recommendations on the future of press regulation and governance” whilst at the same time ensuring the freedom of the press that we benefit from in our society.
The Inquiry is split into four “Modules”.
Module 1 started with Lord Justice Leveson’s statement and dealt with “The Press and The Public”, looking at phone hacking and other potentially illegal behaviour. This Module saw many celebrities at the witness stand, such as actors Hugh Grant JK Rowling, Max Mosley and the parents of Madeline McCann, Gerry and Kate. The Module lasted over 3 months, finishing on 9 February, with over 180 oral statements from witnesses.
Recently Charlotte Church reached a £600,000 settlement for damages and costs with News International over the hacking of her phone and the “unlawfully obtained” information about her private life. In her statement in the Leveson Inquiry she said that she felt that the tabloids portrayed her “as someone who is not me but a caricature of me: the girl with the “voice of an angel” that turned into a “fallen angel” and that she had felt since she was young that she thought the media “were trying to apply the stereotypical narrative of “the child star who goes off the rails””.
Module 2, “The Press and The Police”, deals with whether or not relationships between the two protectors of our society have been in the public interest or not and started on Monday 27 February, with recent notable witnesses being ex-prime minister Tony Blair, ex-heads of counter terrorism John Yates and Peter Clarke and ex-assistant commissioner of the London Metropolitan Police Andy Hayman.
Hayman’s relationship with News International employees was questioned as something that maybe “goes beyond that which is appropriate” and his appointment as a columnist at the Times, which is run by News International, was scrutinised with him admitting to Lord Justice Leveson that “with hindsight” he could see it might have been inappropriate.
Meanwhile Peter Clarke defended the decision to close an investigation, following Royal aides’ phones being hacked in 2006, saying that it was “not anywhere near the top of their concerns” due to dealing with an influx of terrorist threats.
The Inquiry continues…

