Moral depravity stretching from Tottenham to Whitehall
Last Thursday, David Cameron, Ed Miliband and the rest of Britain’s political class rallied together to denounce the abhorrent riots that have swept the country. Mr. Cameron made a robust yet eloquent speech on the moral depravity of the rioters, and rightly condemned their actions as ‘sick’. MPs of course have reason to label the actions of the rioters, looters, arsonists, and muggers as disgusting, unacceptable and above all, deeply criminal.
Yet, if Britain is to dust itself down after the last week’s bruising encounter with a modern reenactment of a Hobbesian dystopia of crime, brutality and fear, people must recognize that there are deeper fault lines within our unstable society that have brought us to this most precarious of tipping points. In my mind, there is no doubt that the brutish lawlessness on our streets cannot be entirely disassociated from the moral corrosion of the upper echelons of modern British society.
Over the last two decades, we have seen a worrying depreciation of the moral standards of society’s supposed role-models. Among the political elite, lying and cheating have become commonplace as a universal culture of self-advancement and self-promotion has increasingly gripped government. Under these conditions, the grounds for altruism, good behaviour and respect for the law have become obscured. In a consumerist world, devoid of a verifiable moral compass, the underclass of our society is simply following this cult of the aggressive pursuit of short-term advantage.
Granted, we cannot point misplaced fingers at government cuts, and rises in university fees to find reason behind the mindless violence of these riots. But, at the same time we cannot simply dismiss the culprits as human detritus for which there is no solution that doesn’t involved a locked prison cell and a discarded key. Young people follow precedents, set by differing examples, which set the parameters of acceptable behaviour. Thus, we must acknowledge the wider malaise of our society. Britain has lingered near the bottom of the developed world’s social mobility tables for too long, meaning that people power- whether offered or thieved- has become the best way for anyone from the underclass or the upper class to get ahead.
Our politicians must bear some of the blame. Politics has always been the looking glass through which people perceive their own existence. Successful politicians must not just protect their people, but they must practice what they eloquently preach. Unfortunately, in recent years our political leaders have appeared all too willing to ignore the principles of common decency and in some cases break the law. From dodgy dossiers, to MPs’ expenses and phone-hacking spin doctors, both Downing Street and the Commons have been caught on the wrong side of Britain’s moral compass, and in some cases, the law itself. The latest revelations about Andy Coulson’s ongoing payments from News International throughout his Downing Street career only underline yet another example of government adopting a ductile relationship with the truth. In response, the public gets no mea culpa, simply a torrent of squirming excuses, corrections and convolutions.
The looters, rioters and pillagers of the last week are proof that a young section of our society has fallen off an eroding precipice: disenchanted, disassociated and devoid of opportunity, they have no long-term prospects to lose but many short-term luxuries to gain. Moreover, at every turn they see the rich getting richer by doing what they want and the poor getting poorer by doing what they ought. Tax-dodging business tycoons, money-grabbing footballers and corrupt politicians set this example and then bemoan the consequences.
This is the dark-side of our unscrupulous market economy. This does not, in any way, justify the perpetrators of these riots or exempt them from apt punishment. However, it also does not mean that we can shy away from the necessity to rehabilitate this lost generation. As Adam Smith aptly recognized, a well-ordered society cannot develop when a sizeable number of its members are miserable and consequentially, violent. The simple truth is that if Britain is to truly recover from its summer blues, then today’s malcontents must turn into tomorrow’s shining prospects. Our society cannot afford to forget John Dionne’s apt reminder that ‘every man is a piece of the Continent, a part of the Main’.

