Restricting the flow of ideas is becoming impossible
Freedom of Speech allows us to decide who we are, for better or for worse. It is the lubricant of our moral compass, the putty with which we mould our deep-seated values. On Tuesday, the French Senate will take a vote on a bill that criminalizes denial of the Armenian genocide of 1915. Leaving aside the enflamed phalanx of French Turks that the approval of this bill will aggravate, it should be rejected on far more universal grounds: it’s complete disregard for the sanctity of freedom of speech.
The impending vote in the French Senate can be mentioned in the same breath as the controversial US Piracy Act (SOPA) that provoked the recent blackout of the online encyclopedia, Wikipedia. But, whereas the latter is an example of government acting with admirable intentions but engineering perverted results, the former fails to even reach any such noble qualification.
Indeed, Tuesday’s vote in the Assemblée Nationale cannot even be said to benefit from morally sound intentions. The bill is implicitly political. With national elections fast approaching this year, it is far from simply convenient that half a million Armenian voters are set to play a role of vital consequence in these elections.
Furthermore, under French law, the Armenian genocide of 1915 was officially recognized as such in December 2001, so why the need for a law policing the denial of this if the state has already reaffirmed it as such under the diktats if international law? In truth, the bill is an extra tag-on that Nicolas Sarkozy hopes to use as a substantial vote winner later in the year. As he scrambles together his bric-a-brac support ahead of May’s Presidential election, Mr. Sarkozy evidently needs all the votes he can muster and is hoping that he can distract as many voters as possible away from the continuously weeping faults of his first term. Unfortunately, the consequence of this is that a human tragedy that should be the subject of worthwhile commemoration and meditative thought has been turned into a tool for political manipulation.
But whatever it’s motives, it’s implications are colossal and fall in line with a much wider philosophical debate about restricting the free flow of information in the internet age. Western legislators are still failing to grasp the inescapable breadth of cyberspace. So called ‘memory acts’ such as this French bill are increasingly ineffective in our technological age, as they outlaw views that are widely available anyway. One just has to hop through cyberspace’s next open window and reveal all.
This ironically broadens and amplifies the significance of these laws as they relate to how we police the increasingly rapid dissemination of information in the 21st century. Information, be it defamatory, insightful or even misinformed, currently enjoys a free abundance unequal to any other time in human history. This begs the question – who should set the limits on this infinite informative sphere? The frightening truth is that it is becoming near on impossible to set limits upon it, however comprehensive your technological endeavor. But, what is beyond doubt is that a paltry, derisive and one-dimensional statute is not going to do it.
In the end, memory laws such as the one proposed in the French Senate enforce a top-down imposition of prescribed views that are firstly, unenforceable and secondly, repressive.
Evidently, we must find ways to limit free expression on the internet, to curb fanaticism and avoid the exacerbation of socio-cultural and religious tensions, but the idea of outlawing an opinion is a dangerous one, and one that has defined many a totalitarian state. This is why the Armenian genocide bill sets such a dangerous precedent. It forbids the expression of a free opinion, however misguided or morally blind that opinion may be.
Restricting the free mobility of ideas is an increasingly ineffective and inflammatory legislative pursuit in the modern world. The internet is now too diverse, too technologically open, and fundamentally too deregulated for top-down legislation to dictate the ideas that one can or cannot hold.
This unchecked freedom obviously offers benefits as well as dangers. Defamatory, derisive or bigoted comments in cyberspace cannot be treated as mere faceless peccadilloes, but we must also not overestimate our ability to limit or control the dispersal of such comments.
Want to react to David’s article? Comment below or tweet us @PalatiComment

