The Eurozone must show solidarity in the face of economic crisis

by David Wynne-Griffith

It is from extreme adversity that the greatest nations rise. And so it shall be that the European Union will either strengthen in solidarity against the present debt crisis, or it will fold under the weight of its own confused contagion.

Walking around the leafy streets of Paris this week, I was struck by a revealing truth. As the Euro stared into the face of dissolution, there seemed to be a severe lack of the Euro-centric fervor so usually associated with la grande nation.

Undoubtedly, there is no shortage of strong opinions on the European sovereign debt crisis in France, but it’s just that it seems that many French people are now on the other side of the coin. Many French people seem to feel no sense of the functionalist spirit that led to the European Union’s birth: solidarity between nations and a sidelining of differences to fit a common regional goal.

This surprising Euro-skepticism is opening up opportunities for discussion on both sides of the political spectrum, from Arnaud Montebourg’s will to ‘deglobalize’ in order to restart the economy, to Marine Le Pen’s policy of reverting back to national sovereignty as the basis of the modern cosmopolitan state. Hardly the sign of a nation ready to stand shoulder to shoulder with its neighbors and march into the valley of financial death.

That said, this attitude seems to contradict plain facts. The French banking system is heavily invested in the creaking sovereign debt of the Eurozone. Several major French banks (Société Générale and Crédit Agricole) have suffered downgrades at the hands of credit rating agencies. International fears are swirling around the overexposure of the French banking system to the corrosive debts of the imperiled Eurozone states.

Although the contagious rumors that have crippled the French banking system in recent weeks may be just bogus embellishment, the crisis is undoubtedly real. The figures speak for themselves- the respective exposures to government and commercial Greek debt of BPCE, Société Générale , BNP Paribas and Crédit Agricole are 3bn Euros, 9.2bn Euros, 14bn Euros and 28bn Euros, according to figures supplied by the European Banking Authority.

Furthermore, the recent IMF Global Stability Report stated that, in the case of a Greek debt default, 7% of European banks would have their entire capital wiped out, and a further 7% would have 75% eradicated. With significant political risks behind recapitalizing banks, these consequences are significant to both shareholders and creditors. The end game of all this is that if Greece was forced to exit the Eurozone, the ensuing evaporation of credit could cripple the French banking system.

However, one can understand why French and German public opinion is dragging its feet somewhat. Firstly, it is not surprising that countries enduring economic turbulence are reluctant to spend hard-pressed resources on other profligate countries at a regional level. Secondly, mutual mistrust between northern and southern Europe is nothing new. It stems from the disparaging fiscal gap between countries, such as France and Germany, who have made significant fiscal sacrifices to stay afloat, and those such as Greece, where people have traditionally distrusted the taxation ethos since as far back as the Ottoman Empire. Lastly, it is fundamentally difficult for French people to accept a Greek bailout package when it will be the poorest fractions of society, along with public services, that will foot the bill. Put bluntly, the latest Greek bailout package is simply a bridge to far for most French people.

However, as the great Edmund Burke once proclaimed, ‘those who do not know history are destined to repeat it’ and throughout history it remains true that monetary unions between large sovereign nations either disintegrate or progress into fiscal and political unions. From the collapse of the Soviet Union in the 1990s to the failure of the 19th century German monetary union, and even the long-lasting Latin and Scandinavian monetary unions of the last century, history is littered with the remnants of monetary unions that existed unstably without further close-knit integration.

And so it seems the Eurozone stands at a defining crossroads. This is not an economic test for the EU, but a historical one. Therefore, although the statist view of many Français de souche is understandable, it is not helpful. The question is not whether the Greeks deserve financial aid, it is whether the countries of the Eurozone have the collective will to march together towards a better future. In the face of a deep crisis, selfishness is a corrosive and contagious reaction. The G20 meeting this week must address the necessity for unwavering solidarity, by boosting the financial clout of the European Financial Stability Facility and indeed bolstering the IMF’s war chest of around $400 billion.

With Western governments financially hamstrung, it will fall on emerging nations to stump up the cash to resolve the Greek malaise. Countries such as China, India and even Brazil are unlikely to offer extra financing to the IMF, and thereby the Eurozone, without substantial concessions such as enhanced voting rights at the Western dominated monetary fund. Thus, we will start to see the rebalancing of the world economy materialize in very real political terms.

For Europe, there is no choice. Re-integrate or disintegrate. The political heavyweights must cross these most precarious of crossroads in unison. The age of national sovereignty has past, and in these uncertain times, solidarity between nations is the most potent weapon we possess.