Vince Cable and employment reform

by Ben Hamer

As Britain faces the ramifications of a double dip recession, the government attempts to stimulate growth and reduce unemployment. Beyond direct fiscal intervention through the Bank of England, changes to employment laws are also being put forward in an attempt to incentivise employers to take on more workers and thus reduce unemployment. As a result, the government faces a balancing act, with a demand to ease demands on business in taking on workers while maintaining reasonable rights for employees. Cable told ITV that he was “trying to get away from a very legalistic system” and hoped to “to have confidence in business that they can hire people … [while retaining] basic labour rights and protection.”

The reforms, the brainchild of Vince Cable, the Business Secretary, that are being undertaken on labour market rules are not only interesting from a business perspective, but are also deeply political, with disagreements between Cable and the likes of the Business Minister, Michael Fallon, and even George Osborne, the Chancellor of the Exchequer. The former Liberal Democrat leader, Lord Ashdown, went as far as to suggest Cable’s disloyalty to the coalition, after it was revealed that texts were exchanged between him and the Labour leader, Ed Miliband.

The idea behind easing constraints on employment is that employers will more readily employ knowing that a reduction in staff will be easier. The government is looking to reduce the £72,000 compensation limit for unfair dismissal. The upper cap, whilst only being awarded to around 2% of cases per annum, was seen as putting businesses off hiring employees.  The voluntary “no-fault dismissal” scheme sees employers taking “settlement agreements” rather than entering into legal disputes with employers. Through giving a compensation package, employers gain protection against being taken to an employment tribunal. These plans are the result of an earlier government-commissioned report by Adrian Beecroft, a venture captialist and Conservative donor, which suggested movement towards tribunal reform.

The idea behind the reform is that employers will be able to both hire with a greater peace of mind, and also remove and replace underperforming workers with greater ease, creating efficient and productive companies. Unions have been vocal in their opposition of such changes. Brendan Barber, the General Secretary of the UK Trades Union Congress (TUC), commenting on the proposals in a TUC press release, warned they were “little more than a smokescreen to erode hard won rights” and would ”not create a single new job.”

The general secretary of GMB, Paul Kenny, took his criticism one stage further, suggesting that such reforms would actually have an adverse impact upon the economy. He said: “In fact the steps being taken here by government, and the ‘noises off’ about it being easier to sack people, will have a much more profound effect on workers than employers. It will increase feelings of job insecurity and reduce the confidence of workers as consumers to commit to spending.

Kenny’s statement shows the hostile stance of the left. Naturally, any reduction in the rights and liberties of workers is contrary to Unions’ interests. Nonetheless, the vitriolic reaction of Barber and Kenny seems extreme. The reforms are aimed to reduce the red tape that companies face in dealing with the recruiting process and to increase their confidence in hiring people. Likewise, while a reduction in the compensation limit for unfair dismissal may seem to be a move against the interest of those unfairly dismissed, in reality the median handout is between ÂŁ3,000-ÂŁ4,000 – over ÂŁ68,000 less than the upper limit. Likewise, the reforms have not fully accepted the changes suggested in Beecroft’s report. The reforms are the product of compromise and of the coalition, and are a meaningful step towards creating a working environment beneficial for both business and those looking for work.