Should the UK switch to a fairer method of degree classification?

by Ben Hamer

The difference between a 59 or a 60 mark may not seem to be a substantial one, but the difference between a 2:2 and a 2:1 to post-university job prospects is considerable. Increasingly, when employers are faced with a large number of applications they are turning to simply removing those with a 2:2 degree or lower from the running. Along with psychometric and aptitude tests, a candidate’s degree, especially at top firms, is used in preliminary assessments of candidates.

Achieving a 2:1 or above is essential in jumping the first hurdle at top companies, where job vacancies come with stiff competition. In a statement this year the head of The Association of Graduate Recruiters, Carl Gilleard, explained that the 2:1 benchmark was the central preliminary screening mechanism for three-quarters of its member organisations, up by 14% from two years ago.

Understandably, many students are angry at the blunt nature of the degree classification system. The difference of just one mark really can have a significant bearing on the career prospects of an individual. The fiscal impact alone is quite clear and measurable: a recent survey by Adzuna showed that graduates with a 2:1 or above would earn on average almost £8000 per annum more than their counterparts with 2:2s or 3rds.

Should such indiscrete degree grading be scrapped? Is it unfair on the students? I would say no. The ‘fault’ is not with the degree classification system, per se, rather with the recruitment management processes within companies. Indeed, were all universities in the UK to switch to an American style GPA system, which would more precisely show where graduates fell in relation to their classification, what would there be to stop companies from arbitrarily imposing a cut off point somewhere along the scale? Nothing. Simply put, it significantly aids the application process, and bluntly cut the wheat from the chaff. No doubt the process loses many candidates who would have been just as, if not more, able to perform the required job as competently as those with a higher mark.

Companies will always employ sweeping discriminating criteria to decide on the suitability of candidates. The painstaking review of every individual candidate may be the fairest and most rigorous process in selecting the very best employee, but is not the best for a modern, efficient company. When facing a large number of applications, removing the 2:2s from the equation is the fastest legal way to reduce the bulk. It is easy to see why employers are increasingly having to do this, as last year, top companies found their applications per job at a high of 81, almost treble the figure three years before.

It cannot be asked of employers to engage in unnecessary and expensive examination of candidates, such as onerous individual interviews and CV screening, when easy and effective methods, such as the results of a University degree, are available for use.

The resulting classification, be it a 1st, 2:1, 2:2 or 3rd, all are a reflection of the capacity for hard work and achievement. Work ethic and academic acumen are reflected in the resulting classification. The ability for clear, analytical thought and a capacity for determined, consistent work are both standards highly valued by employers, and rightly so.

On leaving university with a 2:2, it is only natural for students to feel angry at their narrowed prospects, but it is not right to blame the system. Often those who receive a 2:2, or even a third will be spurred on to action and work harder to overcome their disadvantages and engage in long and successful careers. But if it can be helped, why not work harder now so the benefits can be reaped later?

At the end of three years, you may have many fond memories fun times had in college or out at a society, or even out at Klute, but in the end, the most tangible mark of your time spent at Durham when printing off a CV, will be the name of a University, Durham, and the number next to it. Judging by the prospects of those with 2:1s and above against those with 2:2s and below, it would be a mistake not to try one’s utmost to achieve a 1st or a 2:1. When the former chancellor, Bill Bryson, gave advice to students he told us: ‘don’t let your degree get in the way of your education’. I would further add to that and say ‘…but don’t let your degree get in the way of your career’.