Freshers’ Week fallout
by Sally Wardle
JCR presidents and Senior Freshers’ representatives have expressed their concerns over University intervention in Freshers’ Week.
Unlike previously, this year’s “Induction Week” spanned a full seven days before the start of term, with greater academic focus and departmental commitments for the new intake.
However, just weeks before the arrival of the freshers, the University informed organisers that college bars should not close later than 11pm from Sunday to Thursday. Whilst the move corresponded with a more scholarly freshers’ week, this imposition of policy shocked Senior Freshers’ Representatives who had already planned college events in the JCR.
When notified of the change Collingwood had invested four and a half thousand pounds into two college events, Josephine Butler had booked bands and rented equipment for their “Bar Blowouts”, and other colleges had paid deposits amounting to thousands of pounds. College JCRs had been acting under the pretence that the bars would remain open late, as has been the norm in previous Freshers’ Weeks.
Professor Adrian Darnell, Deputy Head of Colleges (Student Experience) moderated his stance following discussion with College Principals, JCR Presidents and DSU President Archie Dallas. Yet college bars were still only permitted to operate after 11pm on two weekday evenings, and could only do so if granted permission from the principal.
The University claimed that the decision was in accordance with “the Standard Operating Procedures of Bars” during normal term-time. However, University statutes suggest that bar opening times are at the discretion of the college principal and bursar.
The University also clearly stated it had changed its’ position “for this year” due to the “pre-existing irrevocable arrangements” which JCRs had made. This has prompted concerns about the future of Durham University’s Freshers’ Week.
Michael Galea, Trevelyan Senior Freshers’ Representative, fears JCRs will be unable to fight for later bar opening times next year if the University provides sufficient advance warning. He believes this will lead to “more students heading out to town and Freshers’ Week becoming less college orientated and more about clubbing.”
He suggests the “Facebook effect” and Durham’s late start to term contributes to this problem: “incoming students will have had months of seeing photos on Facebook of their friends on alcohol fuelled parties in clubs… When they come to Durham they expect the same so naturally want to go out.”
In March of this year a student group headed by Scott Parker, former DSU Welfare and Education Officer, created the “Alcohol Paper”. The paper proposed a series of recommendations for Induction Week, which was later signed off as University policy.
The Group concluded “college is the safest place for students to be during the induction period and also that we should be supporting our college bars rather than bars in town.”
Those involved in the organisation of freshers’ week expressed their concern over the repercussions of closing college bars early.
Nick Cooper, President of Trevelyan College, noted that “by enforcing 11pm closing times for the majority of the week we are effectively being made to encourage the decision of freshers to go out into town.
“We found that on one of the nights we had been allowed to stay open until 12.30 we had much fewer freshers heading into town and a much better atmosphere in the college”
Siri Minsaas, Senior Freshers’ Representative of Josephine Butler added: “It is a bit disappointing when you’ve spent four months planning Freshers’ week and freshers come up to you in the evening events asking for directions to Loveshack.
“However, they are adults and I can understand why having their drinks taken off them before midnight on some nights would encourage anyone to go out.”
The welfare problems created by the early bar closures and freshers venturing into town alone seem in direct conflict with the recommendations of the “Alcohol Paper” passed through the University Council.
Collingwood President Harry Rylott suggests: “The freshers who will be punished by this policy are not those who will drink regardless, but those who would have been able to socialise in the safe environment of Collingwood JCR and who will instead be forced elsewhere, into potentially unpleasant, uncomfortable, and at worst, dangerous situations.”
The University’s decision to close college bars at 11pm Sunday to Thursday may also have implications for the rest of the year, in particular for college formals. Colleges pride themselves on the in-house entertainment which they put on after the meal, which is often heavily centred on the bar.
Many Presidents are concerned that the 11pm closure of the bar on certain days during Induction Week has set a precedent for opening times during term. This would have knock-on consequences for the format and success of formals, which are so fundamental in creating a strong community within college.
Despite a new push for an academic “Induction Week”, students have complained of poorly organised departmental events and a lack of communication between the University and colleges.
Thomas Bishop, the Senior Man at St Chad’s College, described the induction talks run by departments during Freshers’ Week as “highly disorganised and often chaotic.” The University failed to provide a list of when the departmental commitments were, or where students needed to go.
Instead, one Freshers’ Representative at Collingwood spent four days contacting all 28 departments, compiling a universal timetable of these commitments which he then sent out to the colleges.
However, Thomas Bishop suggests that whilst entire days were scheduled for departmental commitments, these slots were often not filled. Colleges had little knowledge of when students were free, and so were unable to plan events. This left many students with nothing to do during the day.
The utility of departmental talks has also been called into question. – one day the Psychology department sent their freshers on a tour of Queen’s Campus despite the fact that most students will only study modules in Durham City.
Thomas believes that the University should focus on “quality of talks, rather than quantity.”
Throughout this investigation, an underlying theme has emerged: the hard work and enthusiasm of Freshers’ Representatives. The volunteers often work fifteen to twenty hour days, ensuring the smooth running of Freshers’ Week.
Despite anger towards bar licensing and poorly organised departmental talks, most feel their weeks were a success, largely because of the work of these volunteers. Yet, concerns remain over the future of Fresher’s Week.
Michael Galea criticised the University for failing to communicate and cooperate with Senior Freshers’ Representatives:
“While millions is pumped into advertising and promoting the ‘Durham difference’, the only thing that I find different about Durham is a fundamental failure to acknowledge student opinion by the University management.”
Photograph: Durham University

