The dangers of teaching bad economics

by James Murray

Perhaps one of the more alarming, yet understated reasons why we are in such devastating financial turmoil is because the version of economics being taught is hopelessly inaccurate. Yes, even here at Durham economic theories are being taught which are so inaccurate they amount to misinformation.

Take these apparently simple questions: What is money? Where does it come from? These are questions which you would think should be straightforward. However the answers given are often confused and inaccurate, and beset by ulterior motives. The best way to describe the answers given for these questions are that they are the following myths.

The first myth: money emerged from barter. This is a classic and prolific notion within economic theory which lays its foundations. The problem is that there is no evidence that it ever happened. In fact, money emerged out of debt-based relationships.

Before money, human society was radically different and large scale trade was simply not possible. Anthropologists have known this for over a hundred years. Adam Smith, writer of ‘The Wealth of Nations’ asks us to imagine a time before money where the butcher had to go and barter with the ironmonger for his knives – the problem is that there were no butchers and ironmongers before money.

The implications are profound. Money did not emerge from a ‘real’ economy of trade independent of the state by some invisible hand. In fact, in many cases it took a centralised power to introduce monetary systems, so money and the market were the result of state activity and there is nothing intrinsic in them. They existed as a byproduct of centralised government.

Now for the second myth: money today is created by the central bank or government. In reality money is created by commercial banks – well at least 97% of it. Economists are taught that money is created by the central banks and expanded by commercial banks according to a process unimaginatively named the ‘money multiplier’ effect.

The story goes that when somebody deposits money, the bank, thinking they will only ever want to withdraw a small proportion at any one time, lends the remaining amount out. The person who borrows it redeposits this money, which is in turn lent again and so on. This is usually cited as the principal mechanism behind fractional reserve banking, and it is why there is a ‘run’ on the bank when people lose confidence in their ability to repay.

This is a familiar story to economists but in fact banking has not worked in this way for years. Banks don’t have to wait for depositors to put money in the bank to make a loan.

When a bank makes a loan, it can create the money out of nothing by simultaneously increasing the assets and liabilities on its balance sheet. Bank lending is not limited by the Bank of England’s supply of ‘base’ money.

Instead, according to the Bank of England, “money is endogenous – the Bank supplies base money on demand at its prevailing interest rate, and broad money is created by the banking system”. Broad money means the common units of exchange, including cash, notes and the digital numbers you see when you look at your bank balance.

These two fallacies lie at the heart of current economic theory have lead to a fatal oversight in economic policy.

The first myth gives rise to the ‘market is king’ mentality which can be so pernicious when not properly controlled. In the case of the second myth, by viewing banking and financial institutions as merely intermediaries in the economy, policy makers have completely omitted the role that such institutions play in shaping (and breaking) the economy. In reality such institutions are the principal components of the economy.

If we intend to create an economy which functions for the benefit of society, and fosters stability then economists must start teaching a version of economics which actually relates to reality.

The reluctance to update refuted theories can only be attributed to ulterior motives. The current economic syllabus is written from political and ideological motivations. Teaching economic theory as it is is akin to teaching creationism in light of the fossil record.

The problem is that in the case of economics, trying to run a country on myths and imaginings ends in unemployment, poverty and misery.