Student newspapers will be damaged by press regulation
by Ben Hamer
Hundreds of years of an unregulated press in the United Kingdom are coming to an end, with the introduction of a ‘Royal Charter’ that will usher in a press regulation body and stricter controls on content. This Royal Charter will have a profound impact upon national newspapers, student press and, indeed, individuals’ personal liberties. What is almost as worrying is that the legislation was rushed through as a ‘manuscript amendment’, normally reserved for minor changes. The 2,500-word document was anything but trivial, and the nature of the motion left little time for MPs to examine it.
The Charter is the result of the findings of the Leveson inquiry, following the malpractice of certain British newspapers, including the phone hacking scandal. Despite the fact that the offences uncovered were already illegal, rather than putting the breaches down to police investigatory corruption and newspapers’ adversarial and ultra-competitive cultures, it was decided that what the press was lacking was enough regulation. Labour MP Jim Sheridan (who was recently outed for claiming household essentials such as an ‘ivory leather bed’ and a 42-inch Plasma TV under his second home allowance) suggested that the Charter would “hopefully … bring some kind of decency into them [journalists].” Rather ironically deriding “parasitical elements within the press who abuse their position.”
Critically, the broad nature of the Charter and the sea change in the history of press freedom that it has instigated can be seen in the draft Charter under schedule (4.1.b) where it suggests that those who have to comply with the charter, a “relevant publisher”, comprise any ‘newspaper or magazine containing news-related material’ and any ‘website containing news-related material’. This deeply affects student media. Durham’s newspapers, Palatinate and The Tab will be governed by this as much as The Daily Mail and The Times. Despite assurances, the quality of investigative journalism will undoubtedly be curbed, a weaker student press as much as a national press will result.
The Charter could well end up protecting perpetrators of malpractice, hampering investigations in Durham to the same level as national newspapers. Free newspapers help to keep a check on the democratic system: could scandals such as The Daily Telegraph’s exposure of the expenses scandal, or indeed, The Guardian’s investigation into endemic phone hacking at the former News of the World (that prompted the Charter itself) happen under such a system? Furthermore, can student newspapers, the smallest and most vulnerable under this new system, be expected to properly do their journalistic duty? Palatinate, already under intense scrutiny from a wary University, will be placed at an even greater disadvantage.
Indeed, the new system could open up the floodgates for compensation claims. While large national newspapers have the resources and clout to broadly deal with such issues, it is the small local and student newspapers that are heavily affected. Adrian Jeakings, Chief Executive of Archant, one of the country’s local newspaper groups, fears that the charter may “place a crippling burden” on such publications, thereby “inhibiting freedom of speech and the freedom to publish.” Under the new system, complaints about inaccuracies and errors, previously settled without much of an issue, will turn to arbitration disputes, funded by the paper in question.
The Charter sets out (5.1.b) to regulate the “news and information” in current affairs, our “opinion about matters” and even “gossip about celebrities, other public figures or other persons in the news.” The net has been cast widely, wide enough to individuals. Are individuals now expected to self-regulate their own tweets and Facebook statuses?
This Charter, created behind closed doors, passed quickly without close appraisal is a shocking misappropriation of Parliamentary power. Further still, the Charter is to the detriment of student newspapers across the country: some of the most vulnerable instruments of budding journalistic voice. Hamming out an unsatisfactory political compromise that is as broad as the one to which all the political parties have signed up to could be very damaging. Even the Leveson inquiry specifies that online blogs should not be regulated, and yet the Charter seems to imply this. Clauses in the Charter are to be debated tonight, by that great bastion of democracy, the House of Lords, and greater clarity may yet be achieved.
The dangerous vagueness of the Charter makes it difficult to see the full impact it could have upon student and national journalism. While the Royal Charter is not the “statutory regulation” of the press David Cameron promised to avoid, the “Rubicon” he promised not to cross, a precedent certainly has been created, the full repercussions of which cannot be fully understood quite yet. Cameron is wrong, a “Rubicon” has been crossed, but the die has not yet been cast, the full damage not yet felt.
The final version of the Royal Charter is to be passed by the House of Lords tonight.
