British versus American TV – Is there finally some genuine competition?
by Danni’elle Barker
British TV has, for some years now, been suffering from a drought of new and innovative shows. Granted, there have been some excellent offerings from the BBC – the Life on Mars franchise, Luther, Sherlock and Shadowline, to name a few. But with the lack of anything remotely original from ITV and an almost complete void of anything home-grown on Channel 4, British broadcasters have undeniably taken a beating from their American counterparts.
The U.S., in recent years, has offered up a staggering array of original and critically acclaimed shows spanning genres from comedy (Ugly Betty and Desperate Housewives) to political thrillers (Homeland and the West Wing) and gripping dramas (The Wire and Mad Men). Compare this to the British TV schedule, packed full of tired shows with plots as predictable as they are clichéd, and tasteless embarrassing ‘reality’ TV that seems purely designed to spawn the next “heard-of”, orange-painted, talentless wannabes. British TV looks pitiful.
However, is this all about to change? Are British Broadcasters finally being recognised and rising to the challenge posed by the U.S.?
It would seem so. 2012 has proved to be a vintage year for British television. The BBC has been on top form, opening the year with an interesting reworking of Charles Dickens’ unfinished novel The Mystery of Edwin Drood and a dramatic retelling of Sebastian Faulk’s Birdsong. Whilst these shows remained firmly within the BBC’s comfort zone – i.e. period dramas – they were brilliantly presented and ingeniously cast.
Edwin Drood juxtaposed fresh, up-coming talent in the form of Freddie Fox and Tamzin Merchant with seasoned actors Matthew Rhys and Rory Kinnear. Similarly, Birdsong – with its intense amalgamation of love and war that gradually built to be an epic and enjoyable, if slightly depressing, piece of historical drama. The BBC, however, did explore genres outside their usual repertoire with The Syndicate, a rather far-fetched but entertaining tale of five cashiers who win the lottery soon after staging a fake robbery, and the return of Accused. This star-studded, four-part drama demonstrated exactly what is brilliant about British television. Each episode focused on a different set of characters but the plot lines ultimately intertwined to produce a gripping and original drama series. I mean, Sean Bean playing a transvestite – does television get any better?
Even ITV, after years of sitting on the bench, seem to have finally entered the game. Along with the successful return of Downton Abbey, they finally produced something worth watching in the form of their new and intriguing summer dramas.
Leaving, a ‘Mrs Robinson’-esque romantic series, hadn’t the most original plot line but was endearing and believable. However, the real star of ITV’s summer offerings was Mrs Biggs. The inspired casting of Sheridan Smith, whose versatility appears boundless, and the – rather typecast – resident villain Daniel Mays as Ronnie Biggs bring heart and warmth to the story of one of Britain’s most notorious criminals. Smith and Mays successfully and skilfully make these characters likable and relatable which is a true credit to their talent.
Channel 4, however, has significantly let the side down. They only seem capable of producing humourless comedies and insensitive documentaries, replaying tired sitcoms and being used as a puppet by the American broadcasting giants to air their shows.
However, there is some hope in the battle between Britain and the U.S. in the form of Sky1. New, inventive and imaginative shows are continually emerging from this new player. From classic stories such as Sinbad and Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island, to riveting dramas Mad Dogs and the Martine Cole series and fantastic comedies such as Trollied and Moone Boy, which has been deemed, by some critics, as the new Father Ted.
2012 has therefore seen the BBC step up their game, ITV actually participate in the revival of British television and has welcomed a new player, Sky TV. All that is required from Britain to be a genuine rival against their American counterparts is to maintain the epic standard that we have seen this year.
Photographs: Channel 4, Carnival Films

