The Burman Blues: has Uncle Sam forgotten about Myanmar?

By Will Holmes

On February 21st, President Joe Biden addressed a crowd of people in Warsaw, marking the anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. In an uncharacteristically energetic tone, the President reiterated his country’s unwavering support for Ukraine and European security. And once more, he emphasised the principles underlying the conflict, framing the war as one between democracy and autocracy. “Democracies of the world will stand guard over freedom today, tomorrow, and forever.” 

For the people of Myanmar, these words from the president are coarse salt in a pestilent wound.

February 2023 marked two years since the democratically elected government of Myanmar was deposed in a military coup d’état. On the first anniversary, the White House released a statement which addressed the people of Burma directly: “we will continue to support your valiant determination to bring democracy and the rule of law to your country.” Thus far such support remains limited to a largely ineffective raft of sanctions on the military junta. There was no official statement from the president this year. 

February 2023 marked two years since the democratically elected government of Myanmar was deposed in a military coup d’état

Since the coup, Myanmar has descended into a civil war between numerous factions, many of which have been warring in one form or another since 1948. They can broadly be split into two camps. First there is the military junta, led by General Min Aung Hlaing, head of the armed forces, or Tatmadaw. Opposing the junta is a coalition of ousted government officials and members of parliament who have formed the National Unity Government (NUG).

Fighting alongside the NUG and its armed wing, the People’s Defence Force (PDF), is an elaborate web of ethnic armed organisations. The two most significant groupings of these are the Northern Alliance and the Federal Union Army, though there are many more groups and sub-groups active in the war.  Aung San Suu Kyi, the deposed State Counsellor and figurehead of the democratic regime, remains imprisoned over dubious corruption charges.

The people of Myanmar and their democratic representatives in the NUG have struggled to garner international support. They lack any public face. The complex mass of alliances with armed ethnic groups, many of which have engaged in drug trafficking, weapons smuggling and hostage-taking, complicates international relationships. The variety of aims among these groups further embroil the situation.

Perhaps more importantly, the people of Myanmar lack any international figurehead like that of Ukraine

Perhaps more importantly, the people of Myanmar lack any international figurehead like that of Ukraine. Aung San Suu Kyi was an internationally recognised figure, owing largely to the years she fought against autocracy in Myanmar. With her imprisoned, leadership of the democratic movement, now manifested in the NUG, has fallen to Duwa Lashi La. Compared to Suu Kyi, or his counterpart in Ukraine, Duwa Lashi La is an uncharismatic figure who is yet to engage in the sort of international charm offensive that is required.

It would be wrong to suggest that the NUG’s woes are its own doing, however.

The international community has been utterly complacent. Talk of democratic unity is laughable, if not contemptible, when one considers the case of Myanmar. ASEAN, the local political community of which Myanmar is a member, has outdone itself in its ability to do nothing at all. Thus far it has engaged in symbolic gestures, such as banning Myanmar’s generals from attending meetings. ASEAN’s proposed Five-Point Consensus which calls for a “constructive dialogue among all parties concerned,” is at best out of date, moribund at worst. 

It would be wrong to suggest that the NUG’s woes are its own doing, however…the international community has been utterly complacent

ASEAN was founded on the principles of consensus and non-intervention in each other’s affairs. Moreover, it comprises several quasi or outright authoritarian regimes who are loath to act against Myanmar’s junta lest similar action be taken against their own regimes. Hun Sen’s government in Cambodia, for example, chaired ASEAN for 2022, and attempted to normalise relations with the Tatmadaw’s generals. A renewed sense of urgency has emerged following General Min Aung Hlaing’s proposal to hold elections this year. 

Any such election would, aside from being a sham, be an ignominious indictment of ASEAN’s response to the crisis. Thailand, Laos, and Cambodia would, analysts suspect, support the Tatmadaw’s sham elections. Malaysia, Singapore, the Philippines, and Indonesia would likely oppose such action (Brunei and Vietnam are harder to call). Indonesia, who currently chair ASEAN, and who constitute the largest economy in the bloc, have an opportunity to levy substantial pressure on the Tatmadaw. 

Jakarta will still need support, however. China has strategic and economic interests in the country, chief among which is the stalling China-Myanmar Economic Corridor. India has previously cooperated with the Tatmadaw to tackle insurgencies along their shared border. And like China, they too have economic interests in the region. Both will support whoever can foster stability in the region. The West could do more to help resolve the situation. For if Biden’s speech in Warsaw is to count for more than mere messaging, the West owes it to the people of Myanmar to stand for their freedoms too.

Image: totaloutnow via Flickr