Taiwan heads to the polls: democracy in the dragon’s shadow

By Will Holmes

In the run up to Taiwan’s first democratic election in 1996, the People’s Republic of China (PRC) launched a barrage of ballistic missiles into Taiwan’s territorial waters. The bellicose move was intended to scare Taiwanese voters from electing anti-communist candidates. Though the PRC was ultimately unsuccessful, the crisis demonstrated how Taiwan lived in the shadow of its estranged neighbour. Given how much Taiwan and China have changed since then, it is remarkable how, in this respect, so much has stayed the same. 

On the 13th January, the people of Taiwan will head to the polls for their 8th presidential election. Once more, Taiwan’s status and relationship to the mainland hangs over the debate. Yet a growing pool of voters are increasingly dissatisfied with the focus on China. Domestic issues such as the high cost of housing and slow wage growth could easily determine the outcome of this election.  

The incumbent president Tsai Ing-wen of the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) is constitutionally barred from running for a third term. In her place, the DPP are running Lai Ching-te, who has held the office of vice president since 2020. At the time of writing Mr Lai leads in the polls, however he is well short of an overall majority. 

In power since 2016, the DPP rejects the ‘one-China’ policy favoured by the PRC and is a strong advocate of Taiwanese nationalism, identity, and culture. Indeed, their electoral success in recent years has reflected a larger trend in national identity. In 1996, 18% of Taiwanese identified themselves as Chinese against 24% who identified as Taiwanese. Today, fewer than 3% identify as Chinese, against 63% who identify as Taiwanese. 

The people of Taiwan live with an acute awareness of what war might bring

Although the idea of unification with the mainland is as unpopular as ever, the DPP has been criticised for unnecessarily provoking the PRC. Tensions between Taiwan and the PRC came to a head in August 2022 following a visit of then House Speaker Nancy Pelosi to the island. In the days that followed, the PRC conducted military exercises encircling Taiwan, in effect blockading the island. 

The people of Taiwan live with an acute awareness of what war might bring, and few, if any, relish the prospect. The government’s move to increase the length of national service from four months to a year, though ostensibly popular, has disrupted the lives of many young people wishing to start careers. Some are understandably fed up with geopolitics and yearn for a greater focus on domestic issues.

More recently, a controversy has broken out over educational reforms which have reduced the number of classical Chinese texts in the school curriculum. The mainland has jumped on the opportunity to suggest that Chinese culture is being supressed across the strait. That many other aspects of classical Chinese culture have for decades been suppressed by the Communist Party has done little to temper the outrage of Chinese state media. 

Irrespective of whether it is justified, the controversy serves as a reminder of the complex cultural history of Taiwan, and that there remains a significant number, particularly among the elderly, who still long for a unified (though not communist) China. 

The DPP faces other challenges too. Historically the DPP represented the democratic opposition to Chiang Kai-shek’s authoritarian regime. However, for many young Taiwanese they are viewed as the establishment party, and thus suffer from association with the economic problems of the past decade. 

Chian Kai-shek’s rule remains a controversial subject in Taiwan

The main opposition to the DPP are the Kuomintang (KMT), or the Chinese Nationalist Party. The KMT traces its roots back to the Chinese Nationalists who fled the mainland in 1949. For decades the Nationalists, under Generalissimo Chiang Kai-shek, ruled the island with an autocratic and dictatorial regime. 

Chiang Kai-shek’s rule remains a controversial subject in Taiwan. For many Chinese exiled from the mainland, Chiang Kai-shek embodied the hope that China might one day be unified under Nationalist rule. The Kuomintang went to great lengths to preserve classical Chinese culture; to this day the National Palace Museum in Taipei contains the world’s best collection of historic Chinese artwork and artifacts taken by Nationalists fleeing the mainland. 

For others however, memories of Nationalist rule are those of brutal oppression and political violence. The so-called White Terror between 1947 and 1987 saw the imposition of martial law, the execution of thousands of alleged separatists, and the violation of basic human and legal rights.

The modern Kuomintang has understandably tried to distance itself from this violent past. Today they are a democratic party of the centre-right seen by many as an economically pragmatic alternative to the DPP. 

Having once been sworn enemies of the Communist Party in Beijing, the KMT and its candidate for president, Hou Yu-ih, now favour a closer relationship with the mainland. Indeed, in late December Mr Lai accused the KMT of abandoning its former opposition to communism and embracing pro-communist policies. Nevertheless, their non-belligerent attitude towards China has won them support amongst many Taiwanese with economic or cultural links to the mainland. 

Support for the KMT currently runs at about 31%, five points behind the DPP. Under Taiwan’s first past the post system, no presidential candidate needs to gain an outright majority. However, in order to gain a majority in the legislature, which is elected at the same time under a parallel voting system, the KMT and the DPP will, if they fail to win an outright majority, need to cooperate with smaller parties. 

The largest alternative is the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP). Their candidate for president is Ko Wen-je, a former surgeon who won a landslide victory in 2014 to become the mayor of Taipei. 

The TPP present themselves as a third option for people fed up with the established parties and their focus on relations with the mainland. They emphasise the importance of economic development, energy security and pragmatic government, and appeal to a range of voters concerned primarily with domestic issues. However, an aborted attempt in November to team up with the KMT has led many to allege that on foreign policy the TPP are part of the pro-China coalition. 

Though they are unlikely to win the presidential ballot or a majority in parliament, the TPP could nonetheless hold the balance of power in the horse-trading that follows the election. The latest polling puts them at 21%, though they remain a minority in most districts. 

Beijing has propagated large amounts of disinformation in the run up to the election

For outsiders the election promises to be one of the most significant of 2024. Taiwan’s strategic and economic importance put it at the centre of global supply chains. A Chinese invasion across the Strait would undoubtedly embroil the world’s major powers in a direct conflict.

Beijing has propagated large amounts of disinformation in the run up to the election and has been accused by Western observers of a psychological warfare campaign to influence its outcome. Fallacious stories have circulated that the US is building biological weapons on the island, and that they want to blow up TSMC, the country’s largest semiconductor manufacturing company. 

For its part, the KMT have framed the election as a choice between war and peace. The DPP on the other hand have suggested it is a choice between independence and capitulation. In reality, neither framing is correct. A KMT victory would not change the fact that the majority of Taiwanese do not want unification under Chinese rule. The DPP on the other hand are fully aware of the costs of and the need to avoid war.  

Nonetheless, the outcome of this election will shape Taiwan’s relations with Beijing and Washington over the next four years. A KMT government in Taipei will undoubtedly cool relations with Washington and would be a coup for PRC propaganda. A DPP victory would aggravate Beijing and could provoke a further deterioration in cross-Strait, and indeed US-China relations. 

Taiwan has come a long way since the days of Chiang Kai-shek

For the people of Taiwan, the election is more than a faraway geopolitical shift. As the events of August 2022 demonstrate, the results could end up shaping everyday life in Taiwan. On the domestic front, the election will determine how Taiwan manages its ageing population, high cost of housing, energy blackouts, growing inequality, and the cultural divide between young and old. 

Whatever happens on the 13th January, it is important to avoid catastrophising the results. While the dispute over Taiwan is undoubtedly a critical geopolitical flashpoint, we must remember also that Taiwan is a democracy of 23 million people. Their lives are far more than statistics in a great power dispute. Taiwan has come a long way since the days of Chiang Kai-shek; its democracy and autonomy should be celebrated, not feared.  

Image: Taipei City Skyline via Wikimedia Commons