Out with the old, in with the (not so) new

By Will Holmes

When it comes to Chinese politics, images matter. When Xi Jinping walked out ahead of his main rival at the 17th CCP Conference in 2007, the watching world knew that he would soon be named successor. So, when Hu Jintao, Xi’s predecessor, was escorted from his seat at the high table during the Communist Party Congress, so too did rumours spread. Was this a choreographed move by Xi to signal the repudiation of a corrupt and decadent generation of rulers? Or was it just down to the ailing health of the grey-haired senior?

Whatever the case, the moment represents the momentous change China has experienced since Hu was in charge. Back then, China was a developing nation, opening up to the world. Corruption was rampant, yet the prospect of close ties with Western governments was still very much on the cards. Now that very same prospect seems less likely than a lettuce outlasting a Prime Minister. Perhaps even less so… 

After ascending to the Presidency in 2013, Xi began a thorough campaign against corruption which uncovered numerous scandals at the top of the Chinese Communist Party. It also happened to remove a significant number of Xi’s opponents, such as Sun Zhengcai. But in a country where all the decisions were made in ballrooms bustling with Bordeaux-sipping bureaucrats, just about anyone could be convicted of corruption. Then began perhaps Xi’s greatest endeavour — the rewriting of China’s history into a tale fit for the silver screen. Throughout his speech to the Congress, Xi repeatedly called upon this noble past. China has a history spanning back 5000 years. It was a great nation, making “indelible contributions to the progress of human civilisation.” This utopian age came to an end during the 19th century, when, in the Opium wars, Britain ravaged Chinese civilisation for the purposes of self-enrichment. It was only after the Chinese Communist Party came to power that the Chinese people could put this century of humiliation behind them and enter a period of great rejuvenation. 

In a country where all the decisions were made in ballrooms with Bordeaux-sipping bureaucrats, just about anyone could be convicted of corruption.

Most of this is undeniably true. It is true that Chinese civilization made numerous contributions that changed the course of human history. It is true that imperial British powers pursued a cruel and gluttonous war against the Chinese people. And it is true that under the rule of the Chinese Communist Party, China has undergone a period of tremendous economic growth. But Xi’s interpretation of Chinese history is conveniently simple. It omits the millions who died under Mao’s ‘Great Leap Forward’, due to sheer incompetence. It omits the wanton violence unleashed on the Chinese people during the Cultural Revolution. And, in case there was any doubt, it most certainly includes the ‘ball of mud beyond the sea adding nothing to the breadth of China,’ as it was once described by a Qing dynasty official. We would nowadays call it Taiwan.

Whatever Mr Xi thinks of China’s story, it is clear the world has a very different view. The past two years have been disastrous for the Chinese government’s standing, particularly in the West. Their failure to respond quickly to Covid-19, their belligerence in response to fair criticism and their suppression of protests in Hong Kong have prompted a foreign policy U-turn among western nations. This diplomatic fiasco has been exacerbated by Xi’s zero-Covid policy, which has prevented face to face diplomacy for the better part of three years. To make matters worse, China’s once ebullient economy is faltering. A property sector fuelled by debt is collapsing. Local governments, unable to raise sufficient revenue through direct taxes, have relied on property developers to fill the gap. A falling property market means local governments are strapped for cash. Add in a zero Covid-19 policy that puts whole cities into lockdown for weeks and you’re an inch short of an economic catastrophe.  

This is the outlook Xi’s China faces. He has secured a third term at the top, breaking recent precedent, and has appointed a Politburo Standing Committee stacked with loyalists. But despite the certainty of Xi’s tenure, the wider outlook for China looks as uncertain as Hu’s seat at the high table. 

Image: ConexiónCOP Agencia de noticias via Wikimedia Commons