Double threat: ‘Don’t Worry Darling’ and the singer-to-actor controversy

By Alice Bathurst

Don’t Worry Darling is undoubtedly one of the year’s most discussed releases. For a period of time, it seemed inescapable. Every other TikTok on my for you page, tweet on my timeline and YouTube video in my recommended was centred around the film. Whether it was speculation around the plot or updates about the cast drama, Don’t Worry Darling was everywhere. While I don’t doubt our generation’s appetite for a feminist thriller set in 1950s America, I think there was one thing that was responsible for the film’s extreme hype. Or should I say one person.

Despite the cast being stacked with mega names of the industry such as Florence Pugh and Chris Pine, much of the stir was caused by singer and heartthrob, Harry Styles. Don’t Worry Darling is his first leading role in a feature film, and audiences were eager to see how he would perform after his appraised appearance in Dunkirk.

The reviews were not good. The plot direction was hailed as messy and unoriginal, and Styles’ acting was harshly critiqued. Personally, I thought this was unfair: the twist was shocking, the cinematography and sound design was beautiful. In addition, although critics may have been right about Styles, in many ways, his failure was almost inevitable. It was an ambitious venture to put such an inexperienced actor against Hollywood titans, all of whom delivered stellar performances. His awkward line delivery felt even more clumsy when set against the smooth experience of Chris Pine, and his louder moments felt all the more forced in comparison to Florence Pugh’s expert portrayal of hysteria and confusion.

In many ways, his failure was almost inevitable

But this may just be me making excuses for Harry. After all, there have been several musicians who have made the transition to the screen with great success.

One such example is Jennifer Hudson, who rose to fame following her appearance on American Idol in 2004 and cemented her ability by starring in the screen adaptation of the Broadway musical Dreamgirls. Hudson’s screen debut, alongside big names such as Eddie Murphy, Jamie Foxx and fellow singer-turned-actor Beyoncé, wowed audiences through her emotionally charged performance and showstopping rendition of ‘And I Am Telling You’. Hudson’s ability to seamlessly navigate between song, screen and stage was proven in June this year, when her win at the Tony awards made her the youngest of the ‘EGOTs’ – recipients of all four of the major American entertainment awards (an Emmy, a Grammy, an Oscar, and a Tony).

Lady Gaga’s performance in 2018’s A Star is Born similarly exhibits how musical prowess can aid cinematic performance. The narrative of her character Ally’s growth to stardom has poignant resonance with Gaga’s own arc in the music industry. While Styles’ reputation was a distraction in Don’t Worry Darling, Gaga proves how an individual’s real-life persona can enhance their on-screen character.

I would argue that this is also the case for Justin Timberlake, another singer who has tried his hand in Hollywood. In The Social Network (2010), he played the smooth-talking founder of Napster and first Facebook president, Sean Parker. Timberlake’s slick popstar and boyband heartthrob persona amplified Parker’s smarmy arrogance, in turn exemplifying the gawky awkwardness of Jesse Eisenberg’s Mark Zuckerberg.

Playing into his off-screen persona on screen may help him give more authentic performances

Perhaps one of the most powerful examples of a musician who merges musical and screen personas is David Bowie. One of his first major roles was the titular extra-terrestrial in The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976). The character evokes Bowie’s own alter ego, androgynous alien rockstar Ziggy Stardust, whom he had debuted just four years earlier. Ten years later, Bowie once again delved into the fantasy genre when he starred as the Goblin King in Labyrinth. Bowie worked with Trevor Jones to write five songs for the movie, proving his ability to fluidly alternate between medias. 

Interestingly, some critics have hailed Harry Styles as “the David Bowie of his generation”. However, initial reviews of Styles’ next feature, My Policeman (released 4th November), suggest that he still has some work to do before such a comparison can be made, at least in terms of acting. Nevertheless, I believe that Styles should take inspiration from Bowie’s approach to film. I am not suggesting that he needs to be transformed into some elaborate fantasy character, quite the opposite. He needs to remember that he is Harry Styles, arguably one of Gen Z’s most beloved pop icons, and playing into his off-screen persona on screen may help him give more authentic performances.

Image: Daniel Chekalov via Unsplash