Ce n’est pas trop tôt – France’s National Strategic Review
By Will Holmes
The Mistral-class amphibious assault ship can carry up to 40 tanks, over 500 troops and can support the weight of a 33-tonne helicopter. Alternatively, it can carry a 73kg President, as it did last Wednesday in Toulon, providing the platform for Emmanuel Macron to unveil France’s National Strategic Review. The recently released review outlines the strategic outlook and goals of the French military over the next eight years and was ordered earlier this year, following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Unsurprisingly, the review outlined a pivot towards Europe and a renewed focus on strategic competition with Russia and China.
Perhaps more surprising was the forthright manner in which the policy change was made. Operation Barkhane, France’s counterterrorism operation in the Sahel is, by and large, over. From now on, French forces will deploy only in support of local forces. Quite how France can extricate itself from the conflict without a Kabul airport-style debacle is yet to be seen. The report set out ten strategic objectives for French defence policy. First among these was the maintenance of a credible nuclear deterrent. In prior strategic reviews, nuclear weapons have taken the back seat to the threats of terrorism and cyber-attack. In this most recent review, they were front and centre, an indication perhaps of the increasingly fraught nuclear environment. With the growing fear of nuclear proliferation in the Middle East, the forthcoming demise of the START nuclear weapons agreement between the US and Russia, and the increasingly belligerent rhetoric emanating from Russia, the nuclear issue is as prominent as it has been since 1989, if not before.
The review outlined a pivot towards Europe and a renewed focus on strategic competition with Russia and China
To combat this, the French government wants to “redouble efforts to strengthen the strategic and deterrence culture.” What constitutes a deterrence culture is left largely ambiguous, though some analysts have seen this as an attempt to walk back from comments President Macron made earlier this year when he suggested that a nuclear attack on Ukraine would not damage France’s fundamental interests. The report emphasised the need for France’s nuclear deterrent to remain independent and self-sufficient. Indeed, the desire for France’s defence capabilities, nuclear and otherwise, to remain independent of other nations was apparent throughout the text. Similar such desires have been aired by British and American officials, who have become increasingly fearful of strategically important industries being compromised by Chinese firms.
France’s desire for strategic independence is more complex, however. For decades, France has prided itself on walking the line between Anglo-American interests and its own. Throughout the 1950s and ‘60s, France frequently defied American dominance, going against the wishes of President Eisenhower by pursuing its own nuclear weapons programme and at one point even withdrawing from the NATO alliance.
The most recent report takes every opportunity to remind readers of France’s role as a ‘balancing’ power, committed to both European and NATO interests. A European security architecture has long been a wish of French policy makers, who are reluctant to rely on the American security umbrella and its accompanying constraints. Unlike previous French attempts to build an East-Atlantic-Treaty Organisation, Washington will likely look favourably upon France’s prioritisation of European security. For decades, France has prided itself on walking the line between Anglo-American interests and its own according to The Pentagon, represents an acute threat. China, on the other hand, remains the pacing challenge, with the means and the desire to challenge the western international order. As a result, the US military is devoting the preponderance of its resources to East Asia, leaving a strategic gap in Europe that will need to be filled. French willingness to fill part of that gap will be looked upon favourably by US military leaders.
The good news for France is that such an objective is still possible
The seriousness of France’s European threat assessment was made clear by its third objective, which outlined the need for a war economy in waiting. The good news for France is that such an objective is still possible. A result of its dogged independence is that they have managed to maintain a healthy military industrial complex, with giants such as Thales, Dassault and Safran providing significant industrial autonomy to the French military.
Nonetheless, the very mention of a war economy indicates just how dire the strategic outlook is. French military intelligence made the mistake of underestimating the likelihood of a war in Ukraine this February. If there is one takeaway from this Strategic Review, it is that France is determined not to be caught short in Europe again.
Image: Chief Petty Officer Michael McNabb via Wikimedia Commons

