Election time in Israel… again
By Will Holmes
The UK isn’t the only country struggling with its politicians. On Tuesday 1 November, Israelis headed to the polls for the fifth time in less than four years. The incumbent government, a messy coalition of eight very different parties, disintegrated after losing a series of votes in June of this year. That coalition was united not by policy or ideology, but rather by a simple refrain: “anyone but Bibi”.
Bibi, or Benjamin Netanyahu as he is known to the rest of the world, was Israel’s longest-serving Prime Minister, accruing a total of fifteen years in the top job. He has now run again, heading Likud, Israel’s largest political party. The numerous corruption cases developing against him do not appear to have eroded his appeal.
Running against Likud and Netanyahu is a mishmash of parties, the largest of which is Yesh Atid, the lead party in the current governing coalition. At the time of writing, the latest polls put Likud at thirty seats and Yash Atid at 27. Neither party looks close to a sixty-one-seat majority. The other seats appear as though they will be divided among ten other parties, meaning that there will almost certainly be another fragmented coalition.
There will almost certainly be another fragmented coalition
Israel’s proportional-representation electoral system lends itself to this backroom coalition dealmaking. New parties come and go every election and can win seats provided they gain at least 3.25% of the total vote. As a result, parties are generally centred around one popular figure, as opposed to a collection of equally important representatives. After the seats in the Knesset are divvied up, the real process begins, with the leader of each party negotiating to secure the best position in the new government.
Consider Yamina, an ideologically conservative party formed in 2019. In September 2019, just two months after their founding, they won seven seats in the Knesset. Their leader and founder, Natfali Bennet was propelled to the highest echelon of Israeli politics. After another two elections and many negotiations, Bennet became the prime minister in 2021. Yamina’s slogan, “With Bennet This is Possible” leaves voters in no doubt of the party’s raison d’etre.
The focus of this election, and indeed the last four elections, is not ideology or politics. Once again, the question for the electorate is whether or not Mr Netanyahu should return to high office. Netanyahu is currently being charged with a variety of corruption related offences and his trial is ongoing. Nonetheless, he is still popular.
Many Israelis look back fondly on Netanyahu’s uninterrupted twelve-year term, in which they experienced consistent economic growth. Granted, there were multiple outbreaks of violence in that time, but in a country that has become habituated to conflict, internal and external, this is no hit to the electorate. In fact, Netanyahu is seen as one of the more hawkish candidates due to his increasingly anti-Palestinian and anti-Iran rhetoric over the past few years.
Many Israelis look back fondly on Netanyahu’s uninterrupted twelve-year term, in which they experienced consistent economic growth
Netanyahu and Likud’s greatest challenge comes not from the left and Yesh Atid, but rather from the Zionist right. Recent years have seen a proliferation of nationalist Zionist parties, which are riding a growing wave of support in the country. These parties threaten to reduce Likud’s total seats, in turn making it more difficult for them to negotiate a coalition.Â
Just last week, Bezalel Smotrich, leader of the far-right Religious Zionist party and a nominal ally of Netanyahu, was caught on tape lambasting the former prime minister as a liar seeking to ally with Arab politicians. Fortunately for Netanyahu, the opposing coalition is even more fragmented than his own. Most analysts do not see any way for the numerous anti-Bibi parties to form any strong coalition. Unless there is a massive swing in the polls, fuelled by a potential surge in Arab turnout, a Likud-led coalition looks like the most likely outcome.
The results of the election will be published by 9 November. Whatever happens, a stable government seems unattainable. If the polls are correct, Israelis might be best to save the trip home on Monday and wait by the ballot box for the next election.
Image: MathKnight via Wikimedia Commons

