A NORAD Luftballoon drama: security threat or hot air?

By Will Holmes

The state of Montana, nicknamed ‘The Big Sky State’, is at first glance an unlikely setting for a spy drama. Ranchers and bison are rarely fruitful intelligence sources.  But a careful glance at a satellite map of Montana will quickly reveal the state’s military significance. Follow Montana Highway 200 and one will find numerous turn-offs to seemingly innocuous square plots, each with a white hexagon in their midst. Inside these silos lie dormant Minuteman III nuclear missiles, which should the worst come to pass, will light up the ‘Big Sky’ for all the local bison to see. 

So, when NORAD, the North American Aerospace Defence Command, a joint US-Canadian initiative responsible for maintaining the security of North American skies, announced on February 1st that a large balloon was flying over Montana, Congress and the public were justifiably concerned. Three days later, after the balloon had travelled the width of the continent, and after much opprobrium from those urging the White House to act, the balloon was finally shot down over the Atlantic. 

The Pentagon quickly determined that the balloon was of Chinese origin, having tracked it across the Bering Strait into Alaska before reaching the mainland. They subsequently announced that given the balloon’s unusual size and flight characteristics, it was likely designed to gather signals intelligence. The Pentagon caveated this announcement by stating that the balloon was unable to gather any intelligence which could not otherwise be collected via spy satellites. 

The balloon was unable to gather any intelligence which could not otherwise be collected via spy satellites

The Pentagon’s claim raises an important question. Why would China take such inflammatory yet ultimately benign action? Relations between China and the US had entered something approaching détente since November, when Biden and Xi met at a summit in Bali. Limited but significant progress has been made to re-establish dialogues which collapsed following then House Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan.

Why they would send a balloon over some of the most sensitive US airspace when they could have apparently used a satellite instead, remains unanswered. Of course, one cannot dismiss the possibility that this was the singular act of a hawkish PLA General. China’s diplomatic corps and military are known to promote and reward bellicose figures. Perhaps the most worrying implication of the balloon fiasco is that it suggests a breakdown of communication within the halls of power in Beijing.

At the time of writing, three more objects have been shot down by the US Airforce, one over Alaska, one over The Yukon and one over Lake Huron. As far as we know none of the objects have displayed any sort of advanced flight characteristics or intelligence gathering capabilities. The latest statement from John Kirby, national security spokesman for the White House, suggests that the objects were likely “tied to some commercial or benign purpose.” 

Though these latter objects do not appear to represent any kinetic threat, they do at the very least reveal a substantial intelligence failure. The fact that all the objects were able to penetrate so deeply into North American airspace raises serious doubts regarding NORAD’s ability to fulfil their stated mission. 

The Commander of NORAD, General Glen VanHerck explained on February 12th that the organisation had loosened the filters on their radar systems. Prior to this, the sensors were designed to filter out objects that were not characteristic of ICBMs. Though this explanation clarifies the recent spike in detections, it raises concerns that objects such as the Chinese spy balloon could have been penetrating US airspace undetected for years. 

Though these latter objects do not appear to represent any kinetic threat, they do at the very least reveal a substantial intelligence failure

On Tuesday 14th, senators from both parties received a classified security briefing on the unidentified objects. Speaking to the press after the meeting, it was clear that several senators were displeased. Senator Rubio stated that 99% of the information they received in the briefing could be made public and revealed that objects akin to those shot down had been operating in US airspace for years. 

The opacity of both Biden’s administration and The Pentagon has turned this fiasco into a farce. Journalists and the public have had to withstand at times completely contradictory briefings from the White House and NORAD, with neither side appearing to have a grip of the situation. It would be easy to dismiss the events of the past few weeks as obsessions of needlessly suspicious China hawks and UFO conspiracy theorists. It is clear though, from listening to senior and well-informed Senators, that this matter is of grave significance. 

China is currently working to expand their nuclear arsenal and appears to be taking a worryingly keen (and apparently unmonitored) interest in America’s land-based ICBMs. For all we know the PLA is acting with limited, if any, political oversight. Meanwhile, NORAD seems to have abdicated its responsibility to defend North American skies up until last month. In the lack of any transparency, the public can only hope that Nena was wrong about a balloon’s ability to initiate a nuclear war.   

Image credit: Tyler Thompson via Wikimedia Commons