Superficial charity allows the real causes of poverty to go unchallenged

by James Murray

Recently the recently established UNICEF Soc held their launch party, a club night at Market Vaults. Below the advertisements for cheap drinks a slogan on the poster read; ‘Dance the night away, and feel angelic – 50p of every ticket goes to UNICEF’.

To put that in perspective the cost of the ticket was £2. Along with the cheap drinks one might be tempted to think it was a good deal – a good deal for you and a good deal for the beneficiaries of UNICEF; no?

However, far from solving the problems UNICEF aims to address, this form of win-win charity is frighteningly ineffectual. Such charity is compromised by its failure to recognise that the problems it is attempting to address are the result of our everyday lives. Charitable giving in this way only exacerbates the problems by creating a pernicious feel-good illusion, which leaves us contented with our routines.

Closing our eyes and throwing money at a problem we call ‘poverty’ through a vague means we call ‘charity’, simply isn’t going to cut it. Money is not the end but merely the means of alleviating injustice and suffering in the world, and as such the value is not merely in the money given but the way in which it is given.

Many of the problems UNICEF attempts to address are either directly or indirectly the result of the exploitation of land or people. To put your 50p into perspective, it was estimated that in 2004 approximately $607bn left the continent of Africa in capital flight to tax havens in the rich West. Furthermore it is thought around $1.8tn have left the continent since the 1970s though similar illicit outflows.

Raymond Baker, director of GFI, Global Financial Integrity, attributes “this massive flow of illicit money out of Africa [to] tax havens, secrecy jurisdictions, disguised corporations, anonymous trust accounts, fake foundations, trade mis-pricing and money laundering techniques.”

Had this money remained in Africa over the last four decades it would have generated an income more than sufficient to eradicate the external debt, which stood at around $250bn in 2008, and leave over $600bn for reinvestment in development programmes.

Further studies by GFI and other researchers suggest that developing countries loose $10 through illegal flight capital for every $1 they receive in external assistance. So unless we are all going to give a much larger proportion of the wealth we enjoy from being one of the financial brokers of these cash flows, change will not occur.

A criticism often levied at this pessimistic outlook is that ‘something is better than nothing’, but this defence very quickly fails if you consider the larger picture. Instead we find that this form of charity, exemplified by UNICEF soc ultimately achieves exactly the opposite of that which it set out to.

Firstly, the 50p which is donated from your ticket price probably won’t even offset the effects of over consuming cheap drinks. In all likelihood the grain for the drink was grown in a country where UNICEF works. It was probably sold for a pittance to the Western companies, and any profit went to the western company which owns huge swathes of farmland. The cumulative profits probably ended up in a Swiss account avoiding taxation, while the workers saw only a meagre salary for their efforts.

Though this is complete speculation, it is nevertheless plausible. Usually when the price is too good to be true, there is nothing good about it. Trade routes which provide us with artificially low prices siphon money out of the countries in which they operate. Though it is nigh on impossible to trace how it is done, it is unquestionably happening.

Secondly, and most importantly, this form of win-win charity is a disengaging process of giving. It aims to appease people with cheap, superficial nights by telling them that their 50p is helping to save starving children. This form of appeasement charity alleviates only our conscience. It is a transactional form of charity from which people buy a piece of mind.

Consequently, the real causes of poverty, the financial malpractices and overconsumption which occur in our own county continue unchallenged. And it is this compliance with our everyday way of life created by such charity which allows the continuation of injustices in the world. Until people feel compelled to challenge their routine, injustice will perpetuate.

Being lucky enough to be citizens of a particularly wealthy country gives us a certain level of responsibility and influence. In our society the money we spend throughout our lives is considerably more influential than the votes we cast; and as such we must view each pound we spend as our democratic franchise.

We spend money on an everyday basis, and so it is on an every day basis that we have to address the problems of the world.  If we, as consumers don’t demand responsibility in the products we buy then these dubious trade routs will continue to exploit people. If we don’t challenge the conduct of our banks, in accepting and banking illicit funds, money will continue to drain out of the countries UNICEF works in much faster than any NGO can pump it back in.

The excesses and over indulgence of the few has led to the suffering of the many. The win-win mentality which has filtered into charity attempts to justify this excess by appeasing people’s conscience. The launch party of UNICEF Soc is symptomatic of the everyday thoughtlessness which perpetuates injustice.

It is an unintentional albeit systematic and institutionalised abuse of charity and good intentions. In order to help the world we must challenge the everyday; stop the escapism and sensationalism and live within our means, ensuring that our society does so too.

Unfortunately, this requires us to feel anything but angelic.