High Speed Rail- Necessary or Unaffordable?
On January 10th the Government gave the go ahead to plans that will create a new high-speed rail link (HS2) from London to Manchester and Leeds, via Birmingham.
Proponents of the project argue that the ÂŁ32 billion investment, the first stage of which will be completed in 2026, will produce a smorgasbord of benefits; cutting journey times, preventing a capacity crisis on the main north-south rail route, and helping to rebalance our economy by bringing more economic activity to the north of England.
Justine Greening, the Transport Secretary, believes that the new line will be a “transformational scheme” which will “regenerate the regions”. The Prime Minister is equally enthusiastic, stating that: “The things that have made the biggest difference to regional patterns of growth are major transport infrastructure”.
The project is presented as a triumph of modernization; catapulting Britain into the 21st Century by introducing the same high-tech, super-fast trains that other Western European countries already enjoy, and it has strong support from all three of Britain’s main political parties.
The idea of speeding across the country at 250mph is certainly appealing; and a project that will bring faster, less crowded trains is both welcome and necessary.
Yet whilst a grand, modernizing development is seductive to a Government determined to be defined by more than just austerity, others are more skeptical about whether this project really will deliver its promises.
Critics speak of unconvincing economic arguments and use similar projects across Europe to demonstrate this; such projects only reinforced the advantage of a dominant city. More businesses have relocated to the French capitol since the opening of the Paris-Lyon line. Similarly, in Spain, high-speed rail has seen Madrid grow at the expense of Seville.
Thus, some are concerned that far from reducing regional disparities, high-speed rail may exacerbate them.
Critics argue that the inevitable environmental damage, particularly to the Chilterns, should not be ignored. HS2 has also raised debates as to whether the objections by those who will lose their homes should be dismissed as mere “Nimbyism”.
Crucially, the project represents a huge sum of money in an era of cuts across the public sector, and there are concerns that it could lead to other areas of Britain’s vast transport network suffering an investment shortage.
Many instead advocate spending the money improving existing routes; extending platforms to increase capacity and upgrading current lines to cut journey times.
Some are critical as to how much they will be positively affected by the scheme; the journey from London to Durham currently takes 2hrs 54 minutes, however if one was to travel using HS2, it would require a change at Leeds thus the same journey would take 11 minutes more. The extent to which it will benefit the whole country is therefore questioned.
They claim that the planned development will do little to ease overcrowding on other inter-city routes nor will it alleviate congestion on our overloaded road network.
Both these claims are disputed by the government.
Moreover, there is a fear that in order for it to be commercially viable higher fares will be charged, again the government instead all fees will be affordable. Nonetheless, having been given the go ahead, with cross-party support, it seems that the progress of HS2 is inevitable.

