Should Durham students have reaffiliated with the NUS?
I forlornly surveyed the half-empty debating chamber on Sunday January 23rd – supposedly 77 people were “attending” the NUS debate on the Facebook group, yet there were only around 30 people present. The referendum was the next day. When it came to question time, students didn’t hesitate: why had the referendum been sprung on us at such short notice? Why was the referendum in January? Why did everything revolving around the DSU seem so under-advertised? I was tempted to agree with their concerns.
Maybe the genuine problem here was not the DSU President’s outspoken pro-NUS stance, NUSSL drinks prices or Aaron Porter’s supposed motives to surge ahead in the Labour party: the problem was that 210 people were “not attending”, 51 were “maybe attending” and 635 were “awaiting reply”.
The pro-speakers at the debate were DSU president Sam Roseveare and NUS President Aaron Porter. The two opposers were Andrew Keenan, ex-President of St Andrews University, and Chris Sibbald, Honorary Secretary of Glasgow University Union, both of these institutions being non-NUS affiliated. All speakers were articulate, yet only one was red-faced with passion and, interestingly enough, that was Chris Sibbald: the only current unpaid student amongst them.
The proposers argued that NUS affiliation is an opportunity to be represented at a national level; yet Chris Sibbald countered that we should not have to pay around £25k every year to be represented: we can make our own voices heard. But with only thirty people bothered to turn up to the debate, would we be able to fill a bus to London, let alone lobby the government?
However, there are other universities which do not seem to need NUS support. Why does Glasgow University, for example, manage its oldest union very well without paid sabbatical positions? Why do they have in fact two unions, with shops and events that are heavily attended? Why do they have a high voter turnout of over 70% in elections? And, more precisely, why do we not have all these things?
Apathy is the major problem facing Durham University as a whole. The collegiate system, while intensifying internal solidarity, prevents student engagement on a wider scale. We elect our college presidents and welfare officers, but in contrast the work of the DSU and their representatives seems insignificant – one step too far removed from our own lives. Because when it comes to things which have an influence on our future, we, as a student body, remain worryingly uninterested.
The DSU building itself is like a ghost town. The shop closed down to be replaced by the “Activities Centre” – the activities mostly restricted to students eating their lunch or checking their emails. The DSU is in debt. Yet most of us don’t question where they are spending their money.
Well, it’s all online. Looking at the University’s turnover (last year almost £249 million) you can see a complete breakdown of expenditures, such as staff members’ salaries.
Do we ever stop and think; where is my money going?
If we were mostly unaware of the required £25k per year to affiliate with the NUS, what else don’t we know about?
Despite the best efforts of our undeniably hard-working sabbatical officers, the current referendum and its advertisement went largely unheard. However, we all got the emails.
We got harassed; bombarded with leaflets and badges: Durham has been flooded with volunteer NUS campaigners – for the pro side, I might add. But whatever efforts are made, most of us just press “delete”.
It seems that, after almost four years at Durham, nothing much has changed.
The vibrancy of student politics in other universities is hardly felt in our remote, north-east location: it’s as if we’re in hibernation, wrapped up in the longstanding “somewhere in the UK top ten” reputation.
So I voted yes to the NUS referendum. I would like that we didn’t have to “pay to be represented”.
I would love that we had the strength and capacity to represent ourselves.
For me, this isn’t about making sure we can acquire different types of lager in Kingsgate or my 10% discount at Topshop; this is about the fact that I don’t feel like our internal student body has the capacity to support me.
We are totally in the dark and we can’t blame the under-advertisement of debates, the NUS or the watery words of Aaron Porter. We have to admit, that deep down, most of us just don’t care enough. Did you even notice the Facebook group?
Jonny Arnold says NO:
Allow me to explain why the decision to re-affiliate with the NUS was the wrong one.
To begin, let me fire a poison-tipped arrow through those who voted ‘Yes’ to keep their Topshop discount. The NUS logo means very little to the person behind the counter, who looks for a piece of plastic with a university’s name and an awful photo of you on it. Yes, they should only give discount to NUS members, but I think it’s safe to say that not many will look for it.
Let me explain how much that Topshop discount is: it cost £24,801.03 to be affiliated with the NUS this year. That’s a lot of money. £24,801.03 could allow the DSU to refurbish – and I don’t mean converting more rooms into ‘study spaces’, I’m talking about things that students want. £24,801.03 could go towards funding societies in their development. £24,801.03 could be used to bribe Topshop to give Durham students a discount too. Regardless of where you think the money should go, I’m sure that most will agree that it should stay in Durham, rather than the NUS.
A look at affiliation costs in the past reveals an alarming trend: for 2009/2010, the cost was £18,584. The year after, it was £24,801 – a 33% increase. Assuming the affiliation cost goes up again at the same percentage, this figure becomes an excruciating £39,202 bill for the DSU to cough up in 2011/2012. The longer we stay affiliated, the more we will pay to this dismal organisation.
Next, we set fire to those who voted ‘Yes’ for the booze discounts offered by the NUS’ commercial arm, the NUSSL. Looking at the Cost Benefit Analysis supplied by Durham Student’s Union sadly has made direct comparison somewhat obtuse: a table of prices for beverages supplied by other wholesalers was presented alongside similar prices from the NUSSL and this was riddled with inaccuracies. It suggests, amongst other things, that a bottle of wine is the same price as a glass from the NUSSL, and that £19.24 is a lower price than £18.99. Not only this, but rather than state the amount of discount the author has simply highlighted the cheapest option – in other words, the NUSSL. Please forgive me when I ignore the author’s comment that “the NUSSL does tend to offer better prices”, despite NUSSL Amaretto being five times more expensive than wholesalers.
Written in the contract to the NUSSL is a clause forbidding the union to purchase from any other vendor, such as a cheaper wholesaler, without their written consent. Economists refer to this as a monopoly, and is frowned upon for good reason.
My favourite thing about the NUSSL is that it costs another £300 to actually use their ‘services’. That’s right, an extra £300 for restricted choice and, in general, no discounts.
The DSU have certainly seemed less than impartial in the matter: the ‘Yes’ campaign was headed by none other than the President of the DSU, despite it being suggested that he was only voting in a personal capacity.
Similarly, the online voting page featured two ‘Yes’ articles and one ‘No’ article for the vast majority of the voting period, with no obvious way to spoil ballots.
Perhaps the Sabbatical Officers are clutching the NUS’ training schemes close to them for comfort – yes, those courses that the DSU pays for, adding an extra £6,000 to the NUS’ coffers. In reports back from NUS conferences (which the DSU also pay for, an extra £5,000), it is stated that “the NUS is unrepresentative of the vast majority of students”.
Next, I would like to offer some advice to the DSU: there is only a certain amount of publicity you can distribute before you start annoying people. After a look through my inbox and a ponder back to referendum week, I had about 8 e-mails from several organisations encouraging me to vote in the referendum. I then had two people ask me while I was heading to lectures whether I had voted in the referendum. This is annoying nuisance, which drove a friend of mine to such distraction that he deliberately didn’t vote. I know that representation is low, but there are better ways than hounding people down until they vote. The DSU offered students the power of democracy: if they don’t care, then respect their decision the first time they are asked.
Finally, I put the NUS in sights of my dung-filled trebuchet. The NUS is not the organisation suggested by their propaganda. It is designed to be a representative body of students nationwide. It is not stated anywhere on the website that they are, to quote Andy, a Durham student attending an NUS conference in 2008, “heavily infiltrated by the distant left who do not live in the same reality as the rest of us and have views held by only a small fraction of the student body”. What the NUS has become is a political playground for those involved as they wait for their ‘House of Commons fresher parents’ to come and pick them up.
It appears that “time heals”, given that some people are unaware of the reasons for disaffiliating in the first place. We disaffiliated in 2009 because the NUS tried to stop a BNP candidate from speaking at a Durham Union Society debate in light of the General Election that year. The NUS threatened to send coaches of angry students up to Durham to protest against this fair and honest debate, albeit with a controversial figure. The NUS does not seem to be a supporter of truly free speech – a key component of a democratic system, and one that I would like to keep.
The NUS is an organisation that enchants unions as a way of representing students on a national level and deliver discounts to their members. However, once you cross their palm with gold (lots of gold) you discover that the representation you receive often seems to be their own, and that those discounts you were looking for were nothing more than smoke and mirrors.
When the next referendum comes (and it’s close to an annual fixture now) then read through the material for both sides. Attend debates and question those speaking. Whatever you do, think about your vote and your union.

