Obama and Sarkozy: A special relationship

By James Ufland

“We don’t have a stronger friend and a stronger ally than Nicolas Sarkozy, and the French people”, were the offending words uttered by President Obama as he greeted the French President outside the White House. It might have just been intended as a polite platitude rather than a profound pronouncement, but it still came as a shock to the system.

How times have changed. It was only in 2003 that the House of Representatives officially renamed French fries “freedom fries” in protest at France’s opposition to the war in Iraq, whilst Tony Blair was being presented with America’s highest civilian honour. Fastforward to 2011 and whilst Nicolas Sarkozy was being feted in Washington DC, across the pond the last rites were being administered to what Winston Churchill first described as the “special relationship” between the United Kingdom and the United States.

Truth be told the 70-year-old “special relationship” has been on the rocks for some time. And, ironically, the seeds of this particular break-up were sown during those halcyon days of 2003, when the union seemed truly enduring. First formed after the shared experience of the Second World War and cemented by the successful struggle against the USSR and the victorious First Gulf War; the “special relationship” has unravelled in the aftermath of the Second Gulf War, a war that has proved impossible to win.

On both sides, the perceived failure of the Iraqi mission and the ongoing tribulations of the War on Terror have provoked a re-evaluation of not so much foreign policy, but rather strategy. Where there was once was unilateralism, there is now multilateralism. The Bush years taught America the value of global co-operation, the Blair years taught Britain the drawbacks of playing the role of America’s ‘poodle’. American and British troops are still fighting side by side in Afghanistan and economic relations are still strong but the two countries are no longer the best of friends. The “special relationship” has become just another relationship.

In recent times, the premature release of the Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset al-Megrahi and the BP oil spill in the Gulf have driven the once bosom allies further apart. On these shores, fingers have been pointed at President Obama and his perceived personal anti-British bias (his grandfather was tortured by the British army in Kenya). In the States, a shift in British rhetoric and approach has been noted. ‘Solid not slavish’ ties with the USA is the mantra of the new British government. No longer standing shoulder-to-shoulder with America but rather keeping her at arm’s length.

However, is this demise of the ‘special relationship’ really in the interest of both sides? As the ‘junior partner’, we surely have the more to lose. British influence in the world is wavering. The experience of the seemingly interminable struggle in Afghanistan and our cavernous budget deficit will make future ventures onto the world stage less ambitious and decisive. But, after being accustomed to playing an important role in global politics for so long, are we really ready for such a dramatic retreat from world affairs?

The obvious alternative to the “special relationship” is the EU, but to many Britons it remains a dirtier word than even George Bush. Further integration into Europe and a common European foreign policy as envisaged by the Lisbon treaty? No, thank you. To go from being an independent voice to one of twenty-seven is hardly a step forward. As recent events have shown anyway, the dream of a cohesive European super-state is thankfully still precisely that.

Much has been said recently about the growing power of the so-called BRIC countries – do any of they offer a better option than the US? Brazil? Not enough in common. India? Promising, although the nation still has a long way to progress, both economically and politically. Russia and China? Three words spring to mind: human rights record.

So, on reflection perhaps the “special relationship” wasn’t that bad after all. And despite the rather sniffy claims of some of their diplomats, will America find a better ally than good ol’Blighty? Nicolas Sarkozy might be willing to accept Obama’s praise now, but not so long ago he was only too happy to inform reporters that the President was “not always up to standard on decision-making and efficiency”. Their mutual love-in seems to be based more on practicality (Sarkozy is currently President of the G20) than a shared ideology. A modern day Reagan and Thatcher they are not.

For all our differences, America and Britain still share a unique bond in today’s world. Not just a common language and increasingly common culture, but also a common heritage and world view. Yes, we might find them too religious and extreme for our liking, but the world we live in today is very much an American-shaped world. And although our influence may be limited, surely it is better to be the ‘junior partner’ to the world’s superpower than an independent power to whom nobody listens. The “special relationship” might no longer be “special”, but an Anglo-American alliance still serves the interests of both parties