Foreign aid is a waste of money

By James Cochrane-Dyet

Few would begrudge the Government’s commitment to give 0.7% of gross national product as developmental aid, even in these times of economic hardship, but only under the assumption that aid was working. In reality, foreign aid is often wasted, misallocated and, in cases, detrimental to its fundamental objectives.

In light of this, I suggest that the parlous state of public finances in Britain as we enter the New Year provides a perfect, albeit controversial, opportunity for British taxpayers to end the post-colonial developmental aid experiment and the chance to explore more practical (not to mention cheaper), solutions to Africa’s problems.

In the last half century, free and independent African nations have seen very little of the growth and development of their economically accelerating counterparts both east and west. Poverty remains endemic, democracy a facade, and in numerous cases the UN Millennium Development Goals seem as distant and unrealistically optimistic as they ever have been.
Malawi, where my family lives, is the fourth poorest country in the world despite receiving huge sums of aid from the UK and others during 47 years of independence.
Thousands of teachers, doctors, nurses, and millions of pounds better off, Malawi’s GDP is currently almost 30% aid from overseas, and yet it has fallen from the promise of independence to its current Foreign Office classification as a “fragile state”.

Africa’s persistent attachment to developmental aid is mirrored in the policies of its aid donors, and Britain is no exception. The Tories traditionally maintained a deep scepticism regarding the virtues of foreign aid, says Peter Osborne in The Daily Telegraph.

Yet today they share the conviction of nauseating celebrity do-gooders Bono and Bob Geldof and share in their narcissist orgy of megalomaniac money-throwing. While other government departments have made difficult sacrifices, the Department of International Development (DFID) will see its £8.7 billion budget rise by an enormous 37% over the next four years to meet the 0.7% target.

Surely, as many African countries celebrate fifty years since independence, the UK should be gradually stemming the flow of developmental aid that Africans receive, not increasing it with patronising consistency? Where is the exit strategy and most importantly, where is the economic growth?

In light of the recent report by humanitarian group Human Rights Watch, which shows in considerable detail how incapable DFID is of monitoring, for example, its £300 million annual contribution to Ethiopia, are our government’s convictions not  embarrassingly naive? Human Rights Watch illustrated the intolerable use of British taxpayers’ money to reward loyalty within the Ethiopian dictator Meles Zenawi‘s regime of clientelist vultures.

Sadly, the same story is true across much of the continent and cases of successful developmental aid such at that used at the South Sudan Referendum earlier this month are sadly outweighed on a massive scale by aid that is squandered beyond accountability and often in direct contradiction to its developmental objectives. Moreover, while DFID’s foreign aid is increasing, its administrative budget is being cut back mercilessly, dooming its monitoring role to failure and making promises of future “checks and balances” increasingly futile.

Having spent over ten years living in Africa, I must be clear that the target of my criticism is not the work of NGOs which often tirelessly and selflessly endeavour to better human lives (although many are overly bureaucratic, uncoordinated and out of touch). However, much of Africa is still dirt poor and, in terms of British foreign aid, charity is not working according to its objectives; indeed, in many cases it does little more than stunt growth and subsidise bad governance.

As a generous spirited nation, if the British people really want to see African development happen, then let us abolish the Common Agricultural Policy, which keeps African agricultural exports out of the European market, tilts the global playing field, and condemns Africa to chronic underdevelopment.

It is specifically this extraordinarily bad policy, combined with poor governance and suffocating bureaucracy which prevents Africans from taking their own initiative and lifting themselves out of poverty independent of the pretensions of European intervention, and independent of European (and increasingly Asian) conditions and colonial legacies.
Andrew Mitchell, the Secretary of State for International Development, speaks of a “moral imperative” to combat poverty around the world, and many Africans couldn’t agree more.

Andrew Mwenda, Ugandan journalist, founder and owner of The Independent, Uganda’s premier current affair’s news magazine, is one of them.

In a recent letter to The Times, he appeals to an absent British rationality: “The British have a unique opportunity to cut the deficit and help Africa: please, ask your new government to stop your aid!”

Though regrettably falling beyond the narrow scope of this article, I recommend the writings of economist Peter Bauer who maintains that foreign aid handicaps economic growth by sowing the seeds of corruption and complacency, and destabilizing civil society.

For a more recent take, Zambian-born Dambisa Moyo’s book, ‘Dead Aid’, which though labelled “provocative and incendiary” by the narrow-sighted dinosaurs of antiquated philanthropy, is a fascinating critique of foreign aid.

Placing a very large question mark over the trajectory of political development in Africa, and supported by Former UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan among others, Moyo makes a compelling case for a new approach to Africa.

Destroying the myth that aid works, she says, means making charity history.