The United Kingdom asylum system is not fit for purpose
By Jennifer Le

If only refugees who arrive in the UK could be offered a support system that attends equally to their needs, and inspires prospects that are as bright. Unfortunately this is often far from the case.
Many have undergone horrific ordeals prior to seeking asylum, such as torture, rape or loss of a loved one. Others are denied basic human liberties in their own country, and are fleeing from persecution for their religious or political beliefs. They are forced to leave their country in order to have any hope of survival; and even on arrival in the UK, their safety is rarely guaranteed.
You might argue that any experience in the UK is some improvement on life in a conflict zone, but when a refugee states in a hearing that his transition felt like “jumping out of the frying pan and into the fire,” you are forced to think otherwise. The Independent Asylum Commission review also concluded that the system of recent years could not be deemed “fit for purpose”, a term simply confirming the application of the system as firm, fair, and humane – the fundamental characteristics of what you might consider an efficient human rights system.
So what are the main issues? Testimonies of past asylum seekers have detailed experiences where Home Office officials simply show a lack of understanding for applicants’ situations, and subsequently failure to make a fair decision.
A young Iranian named Afshin told the BBC about his application for asylum in the UK, followed by a five year wait which eventually resulted in a refusal. The system appears to dance around the details and create unnecessary loopholes to avoid decisions, whereas it should be committed to resolving these issues fairly and efficiently.
The result is often several years lost in a kind of international limbo with no real integration in the UK, and absolutely no way of returning safely to their country of nationality.
Those in the process of applying for asylum are also denied the right to work in the UK, and in many cases even voluntary work is not permitted.
So although they have been perfectly qualified for a particular profession in their former country, the UK asylum system forces them into a gap in their career, making it all the more difficult to work their way back into the job market following their outcome.
Another problem is that the system is based upon restrictive and out-dated definitions. Since 1951, the United Nations Refugee Convention has been the cornerstone of the UN’s efforts to help and protect refugees worldwide.
The convention defines a refugee as someone who is outside of their country of nationality and has a well-founded fear of persecution because of their race, religion, political opinion, nationality or membership of a social group.
The problem of having such a rigid definition is that, despite being years old, modern practice refuses to adapt itself to new needs that evolve with cultural and social change.
The emancipation of women in the Middle East, and environmental refugees would not be covered by the current convention, yet this does not go to say that their application for asylum is any less genuine.
So when people come to UK seeking sanctuary, only to be confronted with new forms of hostility and new found obstacles, the situation says little about the humanity of our society. It also does little to improve the UK’s international reputation. However, if the value of a multicultural society has shown that it can be fostered within the student population, then it has the potential to reach the wider community.
STAR (Student Action for Refugees) works to push for improvement in the UK asylum system through petitions. Volunteer projects that build direct relations with current refugees also helps to improve their experiences in the UK, as well as providing students with an insight to the reality of the situation, and shaping a more positive reception of refugees in the future.
On Wednesday 23rd February, STAR is hosting Asylum Dialogues, a play by ‘Ice and Fire’ – a theatre company who distinguish themselves by exploring human rights stories through performance. This will be followed by a few words from the director.
If you are interested in finding out more about the issues that are implicated in the asylum system, sharing your own views on the subject, or simply the power of theatre, the event is free, and you are most welcome to attend.
AsylumDialogues
Wednesday 23rd February
Leech Hall (St. John’s College) 7pm
Free Entry
