The rainbow line between faith and the law

By Michelle Wisson

It has been hard to escape the media furore over the gay couple, who have just been awarded ÂŁ1,800 each in compensation from the Christian Bed & Breakfast owners who refused to let them stay.

As the debate has swelled, the NGO Liberty has acted in the interests of the gay couple supported by the Human Rights and Equality Commissions, whilst the Christian Institute has funded the defence.

It galvanizes opinions because the issue of liberty is varied and subjective.  Both sides claim their liberty has been restricted.  Martin Hall and Steven Preddy believe they were discriminated against when they were denied equal access to the Bed & Breakfast Hotel as a homosexual couple.

The Bulls, the Christian couple in question, think that their liberty to follow their own conscience in their own home and only offer double beds to married customers has been stolen from then.

As the Bulls are set to appeal this ruling, the debate continues.  It must be clarified into two distinct areas: what the law states and why these laws should underpin a supposedly liberal society.

Of incredible significance is that the law follows the liberal distinction between the public and the private. Thus while the couple have not incited hatred for homosexuals and tried to impose their opinions on others, the fact that they run a business in the service industry means that their “convictions” do not have a place in this public sphere.

Privately, they may hold their opinions on premarital sex.  However, the Equality Act (Sexual Orientations) regulations 2007 makes illegal regulations which prohibit the provision of goods, services, facilities, education and management on the grounds of sexual orientation.

Defenders have pointed to the fact that the Bulls had explained clearly on their website that they will not provide double beds for unmarried customers because of their beliefs.

However, statements of illegal practice do little to mitigate the legality of something laid down in statute law. Moreover, others have pointed to the fact that the wording of their disclaimer shows it is a judgement related to sexual conduct outside of marriage happening under their roof, rather than a statement of outright homophobia.

The gay couple, who are joined in civil partnership, could never qualify to stay in the Chymorvah Hotel, making it an issue of their sexual orientation.

The unfortunate Chris Grayling speculated that the distinction in the Bulls’ favour was that they were trying to regulate what happened in the own home they lived in, but this is not laid out in law.  No one has forced the Bulls to work in the service industry, where laws have been instituted to protect against discrimination.

Of course the answer to whether these laws are just is more subjective than the interpretation of the law. When a society has a heterogeneous collection of moral viewpoints, there is a healthy pluralism of competing ideals. Hazelmary Bull has linked her case to the marginalization of Christian views.

Yet she must accept that in a liberal society no religion has a monopoly on what is morally acceptable. Repeatedly, supporters of the gay couple have questioned how quickly the legal dispute would have been resolved if they had been turned away due to religion or race.

Let us question in what way this case is different from stopping black people from sitting on buses or putting up signs in pubs that say “No Irish Allowed”?

Essentially, the hotel creates a segregation between customers who do and don’t qualify to stay and that is, to be generous, at least passive discrimination.  The difference in this case is the societal respect, which actually does exist for Christian morals.  There is no societal respect in the same way to justify denying someone on the grounds of race, which would be deemed far more abhorrent and antiquated.

Therefore, I would argue that, in fact, the prevalence of Christian morality, underscoring British history, may be decreasing, but still exists or such a debate would never have exploded in such a way. Many are compassionate for the Bulls, who are acting out of faith and religion, which the judge has explicitly stated does not appear malicious in intent. This is why they have been granted their appeal.

However, despite it being their business, their house and their consciences, they were both unfair and illegal.

Throughout history, social movements have found discrimination is often systemic below the surface. As the struggle for feminism propelled into radical depths in the 1970s, it was the all-pervasiveness of the system of “patriarchy” restricting women that led women to protest that “the private is the public”.

In this liberal society, the debate is not to stop the couple from having private views against premarital sex. That is their choice; their liberty connected to their religion.

There cannot be places for heterosexual couples but not homosexuals; a feeling of us and them. It is unhealthy and is part of the systemic sexual discrimination which exists, exemplified in crimes against homosexuals such as the recent murder of a gay civil servant.

Mrs Bull reacted to the judgement by saying that “Much has been said about equality and diversity but it seems that some are more equal than others”. She misses the point. In a liberal society there cannot be some discrimination which is more equal than others. It all must be curbed to allow all views and all peoples to exist alongside each other.