"You can protect yourself without giving up your freedoms"
An eminent human rights lawyer at Matrix Chambers before his most public appointment to date, Sir Ken was knighted in the 2007 New Year Honours for services to justice, and arrives in Durham to argue in a Union Society debate that civil liberties should not be sacrificed for national security interests.
“I’m absolutely delighted,” he enthuses as the subject of Guantanamo Bay’s closure is broached. “I’m quite sure that it’s the right thing to do. President Obama said in his inauguration speech, and it seemed to me that this was a direct comment on the previous eight years, that there’s no conflict between our security and our values. What he meant by that was, I think, that you can protect yourself without giving up your freedoms and I agree about that.
“He’s absolutely right to close down Guantanamo, he’s absolutely right to close down those detention centres, he’s absolutely right to put a stop to torture.”
In total, 775 prisoners have been detained at the camp since its first inmates arrived in January 2002. Many have since been freed or transferred to foreign governments, but 245 men remain in custody. Given that such a large proportion of these terror detainees have been freed or transferred, and given that criminal proceedings are ongoing for some of the camp’s current inhabitants, was the use of Guantanamo Bay an excessively impulsive measure on the part of the Bush administration?
“I think it damaged America’s image in the world, and I don’t think it helped them defeat al-Qaeda, in fact quite the opposite. What happened at Abu Ghraib, what’s happening at Guantanamo was assistance to al-Qaeda.”
And what about President Obama’s decision to request a 120-day suspension for the trials of five men accused over the September 11th attacks?
“He was right about that too. Even the military lawyers involved in those trials are uneasy about them. He’s obviously got a very complicated issue about what to do with those detainees. I’m sure at least some of them are dangerous people.
“The problem is I don’t think they’ve got evidence that would be admissible in a normal court against many of these guys, because some of the evidence would come from waterboarding. I myself am convinced this is a form of torture and you could not use that.”
The British Government has in recent days asked its European counterparts to resettle inmates from Guantanamo Bay, with Portugal and Germany – at the time of writing – coming forward to offer their assistance. Sir Ken claims that for Britain to accept detainees would “not be a very good idea”, adding that “Guantanamo has created an enormous problem for the States”, but that it’s “obviously right to close it down”.
Sir Ken himself was an outspoken critic of the government’s plans to increase the period of detention without charge from 28 days to 42 days in exceptional circumstances, stating in front of a parliamentary committee that the police had “coped comfortably” within the current framework. He explains: “I opposed 42-day because I was in charge of the prosecutions. We’d never needed 42 days, not even in the most complex cases. When people used to say to me that ‘it’s possible’, I used to reply ‘well, anything’s possible’. The question is whether it will ever be likely.
“I think actually it’s a very broad feeling among British people. They don’t want to lose that part of Britishness. You don’t want there to be the feeling that when you go out on the street you’re not safe from the state.”
In a move criticised by high-ranking government officials at the time, Sir Ken went on record during his term of office to criticise Western political rhetoric since September 11th 2001. “I never liked the expression ‘war on terror’,” he opines. “I don’t think the people that bombed London on July 7th were soldiers. They were fantasist, narcissist criminals. They said they were soldiers in their martyrdom videos. We shouldn’t pay them that compliment.
We are obviously engaged in a struggle against people who are trying to damage us. The response to terrorism is in many different forms. There’s obviously a military response. There can be an intelligence response. There can be a secret service response.
“What I always say is that when acts of terrorism are committed on the street, they’re crimes. They’re straightforward criminal offences and they should be dealt with by the criminal justice system. They shouldn’t pay these people the compliment of telling them they’re soldiers. We made that mistake with the IRA.
“I just don’t like the rhetoric, and I’m sure Barack Obama won’t be using that rhetoric. Indeed, our own government don’t use it. I made a speech in January 2007 about this, saying there’s no war on terror, and I was criticised a bit by the government. Now it’s government policy.”
Jacqui Smith and the Labour Government have this year pledged a full consultation on proposals for a mammoth database that could contain details of all telephone calls, emails and internet use. Ms Smith has previously claimed that the ability to intercept communications and obtain communications data is “vital” to fighting terrorism and combating serious crime. On hearing of the plans, Sir Ken responded in The Guardian days later that “all history tells us that reassurances like these are worthless in the long run. In the first security crisis the locks would loosen”. How can we as a society achieve an appropriate middle ground, an appropriate consensus? “We have a middle ground at the moment,” he explains. “What they’re talking about, and they haven’t yet issued the consultation, is a massive expansion.
“We’ve got the ability to survey people, we can intercept calls. The question is do we want every e-mail, every phone call which anyone may make kept on a single database to which the government has access. Is that where we really want to be?
“There’s no such thing as total security. The government can’t make anything 100% safe. There’s always an element of risk.
“I don’t want the government to have a database that monitors everything I do, everything my kids do, everything my friends do. I don’t think it’s healthy.”
What about intrusions of privacy for criminal investigation, such as wiretapping? “I don’t have a problem with any of that. It’s essential that we target people we believe are involved in criminal activity.
“If I’m a prosecutor and I believe a person is going to be involved in a bank robbery, of course I’ll target them in that way. Ms Smith is right when she says that most serious cases have that sort of evidence. What the European Convention allows is that sort of intrusion if it’s for an appropriate purpose, and the purpose is to fight crime – that’s appropriate.”
On the issue of domestic crime, last year will be remembered as – among other things – a year in which the media profile of incidences of knife crime in Britain was raised beyond any level previously seen. Recent figures have confirmed that knife crime has indeed increased. What is the view of the situation from the upper echelons of the British criminal justice system? “I drive to work through North London, and recently my route has seen two sites where two separate people have been stabbed to death,” Sir Ken recalls. “I think there is some evidence that people are carrying knives more than they used to, and they use them more frequently.
“Gordon Brown invited leading judges, legal experts and police officers to a summit meeting, and we found that many police officers – on discovering a person carrying knife – would simply caution them. We needed it to reach the stage where their cases would come to us at the CPS, so that we could prosecute them. That’s now the case. “The suggestion is that, in areas where this has been richly enforced, there’s some reduction. I think carrying a knife is quite a serious crime, because of what it can lead to.”
When in 2004 the Crown Prosecution Service announced that there would not be enough evidence to bring fresh charges over the murder of Stephen Lawrence, Sir Ken commented at the time that the country needed to “reflect on this dreadful murder”, and to recognise “the profound effect it has had on our national consciousness”. With the benefit of five years of hindsight, he’s asked to explain the comment. “I think Stephen Lawrence had a profound impact on criminal justice, and a huge impact upon the police in particular. The Metropolitan Police completely transformed itself after the Lawrence inquiry because they were confronted with just how atrociously bad their response to the crime was.
“I think everyone acknowledges that there were elements of racism in the way they responded. They just didn’t treat it appropriately. They didn’t treat Stephen Lawrence, his family, or his friends appropriately. I’m sure it wouldn’t happen now. It had a huge impact.”
Voted in the inaugural Times Law 100 to be the fourth most influential lawyer in the UK, and hailed in an editorial in The Times on his final day as an “exemplary figure” who had transformed the office of DPP into a “respected and public role”, Sir Ken’s successor is Keir Starmer. Mr Starmer will inherit a CPS that has changed fundamentally over the last five years, with Sir Ken introducing two big changes: the taking over of charging suspects from police, and the drive for CPS lawyers to do more advocacy in the courts. When asked about the motivations behind these changes, Sir Ken responds: “I think that if you’re a prosecuting authority you’ve got to recruit the best lawyers. That wasn’t traditionally the case for the CPS. They had a very limited job. The police would charge a case. They sent for the CPS. The CPS lawyer would look at it, and if it passed the test, the case would be passed on to a barrister. That’s a very limited role.
“We thought that if we put our own people into court, it would improve their profile and improve their confidence, and would make the CPS a more exciting place to work.”
If one thing can be guaranteed to Sir Ken’s successor as Director of Public Prosecutions, it is that a changing society in Britain – and a changing international political climate – will continue to provide the CPS with fresh challenges, fresh debates, and a continuing need to adapt and respond in the face of profound change.
Factfile
Born
4th January 1953
Nationality
British
Education
Read PPE at St. Edmund Hall, Oxford
Career
- Called to the Bar by the Inner Temple, July 1978.
- Defended terrorist suspects, both from the Middle East and the Provisional IRA, as well as major fraudsters and drug dealers.
- Co-founder of Matrix chambers with Cherie Booth and Tim Owen QC.
- Director of Public Prosecutions, England and Wales, 2001-2008
