Israel’s side of the story – Hamas deserves some blame for the suffering of Gazans
Do they even care?” “For what end was it undertaken?” “Where is the love?” These are the same questions I have heard again and again in response to Israel’s Gaza incursion. Pictures of injured children being rushed into hospitals will always move people, myself especially.
Unfortunately the reasons for it aren’t forthcoming in our papers, or good enough ones aren’t at any rate. However, there are reasons why over 90% of the Israeli population supported the offensive, and it was not just out of nationalism or hatred. This article isn’t meant to make you agree with the offensive, just to give you Israel’s side of it.
The Jews have a unique history; there is no competition with them for their place in world history as the most oppressed people. With a few historical gaps they have experienced pogroms, expulsions and genocides. Israel was thus the product of an idea: an idea that the protection of the Jews could only be assured with a Jewish state, that it could only be assured when they could defend themselves. This is the underlying mindset of the nation. In polls more than 50% believe they may see another Holocaust in their lifetime; many have seen one already. They are surrounded on all sides by enemies who seek their death and destruction.
In 2005 Israel vacated all of its settlements in the Gaza strip. It was a move that was very painful for Israel, but it was done out of a belief that peace and reconciliation was the best way forward. That was their olive branch. A ceasefire was in place and peace was holding.
Hamas then won the 2006 Palestinian legislative election. They quickly proceeded to violently destroy the opposition Fatah movement in Gaza. It was hardly a democratic move. They then started increasing their rocketing of Israel by as much as they could.
Israel asked, then begged, Hamas time and time again to stop the rockets. They made no demands; just asked them to stop. The Prime Minister, Ehud Olmert, went live on Arab television and begged. What could they do? Sit and take it indefinitely? Who would? That they took rockets daily for as many years as they did is testament to their restraint. Can you imagine such restraint from Britain or America?
For so long as Hamas remains in power no lasting peace is possible. The democracy that Gaza had was destroyed by them when they destroyed Fatah in Gaza. They will never acknowledge Israel’s right to exist on a permanent basis. End of.
“The Day of Judgment will not come about until Moslems fight the Jews (killing the Jews)… O Abdulla, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him.” “They were behind World War II.” These quotes are not from some minor Hamas official; they are direct quotes from the Hamas Charter. Indeed I have often remarked on an odd anti-Semitic double-think that they enjoy: on the one hand they talk of the Holocaust with a real joy, whilst on the other they call Iran’s Holocaust denial seminars “courageous”. Can you see why Israel doesn’t like them?
Hamas recently expanded its rocket operation. Iran has been supplying them with bigger rockets – they go further and cause more damage. They housed their rockets in densely populated areas. Hamas knew Israel would have no choice but to respond; they knew they were putting Palestinian lives at risk. Israel warned the residents that their houses were to be destroyed, and when they saw clear signs of residents still inside they usually did not bomb. It is sad that it had to end like this. Hamas knew that if they did just one little thing it could all have been prevented. They only had to stop their rockets – nothing more – and they knew it. It was a cut to their ego that was too deep. Israel’s Gaza incursion was undertaken with a heavy heart, and now Israelis say with no joy that it was a success: before, Hamas was cagey about a ceasefire, now they are desperate for one.
I am not trying to absolve Israel of blame; this is just part of the other side of an immensely complex story. Of course we should feel free to criticise Israel. They often deserve it. But there are many in Britain’s Jewish community who believe that a semblance of neutrality is sometimes lost in our media.
This is a conflict that is deeply tribal and deeply religious; the embers of it will settle somehow. The hope is that sometime – and sooner rather than later – both sides will be totally sick of the bloodshed and will be willing to agree to large-scale compromises. For now we should weep for both sides. Palestine is a failure of everybody, Britain included. However, for as long as Hamas are in government, the road to lasting peace may yet meander.
