On Mental Health Week – A more nuanced approach to psychological health is needed
The keynote poster for this year’s University Mental Health Awareness Campaign, with the beguiling Basement Jaxx slogan, ‘Where’s Your Head At?’ was the image of some blue baked beans among a sea of the regular beans, with the reminder, “depression is
Seeing it, I wondered, how one is meant to respond to a poster about mental health. Broadly speaking, I imagine two possible reactions; either you are affirmed of your ‘normality’ in being one of the orange beans, surrounded by others to affirm your collective majority ‘orangeness’ (i.e. ’happiness’). Alternatively, you see that word ‘depression’ and realise that that statistic is a person – it’s you. You are one of the blue beans surrounded by orange ones that only accentuate your ‘blueness’, and you are outside of the norm.
Yes, there are others like you, but they too are blue and isolated among regular beans. The former seems only to reinforce the ‘us and them’ mentality of those within and outside of the statistics, the blue vs. orange, the happy vs. distressed, the binary of ‘normality’. The latter is a bleak image of isolation, difference and minority. Hands up who wants to be a blue bean? Perhaps it is that ‘not me!’ reaction which would urge us to seek help and support to reduce our blueness. Forgive me if I’m neglecting a multi-layered subtext, but how is that an affirming, constructive or indeed ‘healthy’ message?
If we infer that the aims of a mental health campaign should be to first inform students of the ‘facts’, secondly to reduce the connotative stigma, and thirdly to aid individuals coping with mental health difficulties to feel less isolated, can we see the actualisation of these aspirations in this year’s publicity? Take, for example, the celebrity pin-ups of mental health issues that were up in the DSU and colleges last week. ‘What does Mary-Kate Olsen have in common with x % of the population? She’s had Anorexia.’ So, if you have an eating disorder, you are not alone – in fact someone who you once watched on the Disney Channel after school also had one. So, not only is someone still ‘cool’ and ‘successful’ despite their ‘problem’, but they’ve shown inspiring courage in overcoming this adversity, and well…so can you. Stereotypes shattered? Enlightened by your newfound awareness? Again, apologies if I have missed the major meta-narrative.
The flaw in publicising issues via celebrities and statistics is that we find comfort in the ‘phew, my problems aren’t that bad’ or ‘ahh, at least Cheryl Cole knows how I feel’. Surely such temporary, superficial providers of relief only mask the individual’s own experiences, uniquely shaped and personally felt, in ways far more complex and ‘grey area’ than being a number in the population’s quota of ‘people who self-harm’.
Emotions and psychological struggles or ‘disorders’ are inherently complex, varying between individuals, and can be of tremendous value to an individual. Take for example Bipolar Disorder, which Stephen Fry famously publicised in his poignant series that highlighted the artistic genius experienced in his highest ‘manic’ moments. Now that really is subversive; Fry broke down stereotypes by showing Bipolar Disorder as not always destructive, reduced isolation allowing others to openly acknowledge the condition with a newfound respect, and informed the population of the highly complex and affecting symptoms of the condition. So puzzling and so paradoxical was his struggle that no statistic could ever herd him into a category, or indeed reassure him by highlighting its frequency, for it was fundamentally a personal journey.
I suggest the campaign budget could be channelled into offering discounts at the university gym for those struggling with depression, since exercise is a commonly prescribed treatment to raise mood. Or, the campaigns could be addressed at people who will experience the other side of mental health issues, namely to be supportive of their friends, to listen without judgement or problem-solving agendas. A friend from Grey College told me about the welfare team receiving anonymous emails with personal accounts of problems which were, with permission, sent to the entire JCR each day. Such initiatives both reduce isolation and raise awareness of the frequency that people we sit down to college dinner with may be coping under a ‘mask’ that, with trust and time, they can begin to lift.
I for one am more inspired by Winona Ryder’s words at the end of Girl, Interrupted than I am by binary baked-bean-branding. Mental illness “isn’t being broken, or swallowing a dark secret. It’s you or me, amplified.”
