Europe’s saving Grace – the morality of shopping with Mrs Mugabe

Last week’s Sunday Times published the findings of an investigation into the dubious finances of Robert and Grace Mugabe, the first couple of disease- and poverty-ridden Zimbabwe. The article revealed the first lady’s latest spending excesses on a holiday in Hong Kong, such as a £4m residence and plans to launch a multi-million-pound diamond venture in China’s coastal city of Qingdao.

Such extravagance is hardly out of character for the woman who is often referred to as First Shopper. Although she mostly travels around the Asian continent, where she and her husband are not subject to travel bans (as is the case in most EU countries and the United States), she is famously said to have spent £75,000 in one day during a stay in Paris in 2003, having taken advantage of a loophole in her travel ban. According to the Times article, her travels have been funded by Gideon Gono, head of the central bank of Zimbabwe, who is thought to have given Grace £64,000 for her latest trip alone.

Back home in Zimbabwe, the latest estimates are that unemployment is at 94% and inflation is measured in sextillions of per cent – whilst more than half of citizens require emergency food aid, 20% are HIV positive, and a cholera pandemic has caused over 3,000 deaths in the last six months. Not to mention that Mugabe’s regime has come to be viewed as one of the world’s most corrupt and inefficient, where violence and oppression are custom and human rights non-existent.

Needless to say, the Mugabes’ network of bank accounts and estates across Asia, and the First Lady’s shopping habits have been the cause of widespread anger and condemnation. Last week’s article not only emphasized this but also inspired countless bloggers and members of online debate forums to decry the obscenity and shamelessness of Grace Mugabe’s spending.

To be sure, the Mugabes must be held accountable for using state funds to maintain a lifestyle of luxury while the wider population is rotting away in disease and poverty, and hopefully the day will come when this is done more radically than with bad nicknames and a travel ban.

However, what is to be said of those who accept Grace Mugabe’s money? Every time someone cashes Mrs Mugabe’s payments, they are voluntarily profiting (and in no small measure) from the deprivation of hundreds of Zimbabwean families. The Sunday Times presented some telling statistics: when Grace paid a $15,000 hotel bill in cash, she threw away enough to feed 750 families for a week, or fully treat 250 cholera victims.

State policies have mostly been tough on the Mugabes. Even in Hong Kong, a reported tightening of money-laundering laws is likely to affect the security of their investments. But what of the international fashion houses and luxury retailers that routinely cater for the First Lady’s every whim? Once again, we are faced with the paradoxical lack of political accountability of multinational corporations.

Selling Grace Mugabe a £10,000 handbag is nothing short of a political act. The usual argument, that basic personal freedom means clients are entitled to discretion and shouldn’t have to justify the transparency of their finances to purchase something, simply isn’t acceptable in a case like this. The ‘ignorance is bliss’ policy that is common in such high-end establishments is not only hypocritical but criminal when a highly exposed political figure comes in and presumes to shop with money that isn’t hers to spend.

The political status of multinational corporations is ambiguous, no doubt – but nevertheless undeniable and it is high time we recognized this. Similarly, countries cannot wash their hands of issues like this. The term multinational refers to geographic and economic aspects of a firm, but it does not mean that said firm is free from national identity. To the contrary, the French are proud to associate with trademark names like Chanel, which epitomizes creativity and savoir-faire in the art of Haute Couture. Salvatore Ferragamo perpetuates Italy’s know-how in shoe-making, and happens to be a favorite of Mrs Mugabe’s.

The fact is, when Grace Mugabe wears French couture and Italian designer shoes, Europe is profiting from the misery of the people of Zimbabwe. The failure to hold firms accountable for inherently political acts is just as reprehensible as the acts themselves.

I am not suggesting that large corporations should be subjected to government censorship of their client lists. Rather, I wish to see multinational corporations treated as political agents and integrated into a system of accountability.