Desperation prompts universities to drop fees

by Emma Jones

In the midst of this year’s UCAS applications, as many as 28 English universities are re-considering their decision to charge students £9,000 in annual tuition fees.

This turn-around will prompt a sigh of relief from the Government whose attempt at tuition fee reform has, from the outset, been the victim of several embarrassing setbacks.

David Willetts, the universities minister, was found to be severely wide of the mark when he predicted that universities would charge varying levels of fees amounting to an average of approximately £7,500 across the university sector.

Instead, the declared intention of 47 universities to charge the maximum possible £9,000 gave rise to a much higher national average of £8,393.

Although not required to be paid up-front, the extent of this increase and the greater level of debt it will lead to, has prompted many pupils to question the benefit and value-for-money of a university education.

As a Durham student and member of St. Chad’s College has commented: “People just don’t know if it’s worth it.”

This would explain the 9% drop in applications so far this year compared with 2011. Universities UK chief executive, Nicola Dandridge, warns against reading into these figures at the very start of the application process. However, NUS Vice-President, Toni Pearce, suggests: “The indication is that the confusion caused by the government’s botched reforms is causing young people to at the very least hesitate before applying to university.”

One in ten potential students has, in fact, been found by a recent BBC Inside Out survey to be “definitely put off going to university” as a direct result of increased fees, with as many as half of those surveyed admitting they would consider study options abroad in order to get the best value-for-money experience.

Desperately trying to prevent the loss of student numbers, this latest development in the tuition fee saga comes in the wake of the Government’s higher education white paper.

Released over the summer, this document illustrated the determination to bring about a more market-driven higher education provision in the hope of driving down fees. An incentive in the form of 20,000 student places which will be reserved throughout the application process and auctioned off to institutions offering courses at £7,500 or less has prompted a drastic recalculation on the part of one fifth of English universities.

In light of this, a new timetable has been announced by the Office for Fair Access which will allow institutions to alter the details of their fee rates and financial support packages. These new plans must be submitted by 4th November, with OFFA aiming to inform universities of their acceptance or rejection by November 30th.

Universities have been told that they will then be required to inform students of any changes to fee rates within five working days, whilst students who have already applied must be given the option of staying with the financial package on offer at the time of their application.

In the meantime, however, despite David Willett’s repeated references to the importance of school pupils being able to make informed choices about their futures, many will be forced to debate whether or not to pursue a place at university without a clear idea of the fees proposed by their institutions of preference.

Concerns have mounted particularly over the impact this uncertainty may have on applications coming from disadvantaged students who are already under-represented at the UK’s top higher education institutions.

However, the Russell Group of Universities pleads the case that tuition fee debates must not be allowed to mask the root cause of this problem, highlighting that the key contributing factors are not financial but instead poor performance at GCSE and A-Level alongside the study of subjects at A Level which are not accepted by these selective institutions.

Concerns have also been expressed over the sustainability of science related courses. Not only are these more expensive to teach than their arts based counterparts, and thus the quality of teaching might diminish, but they also often have lower entry requirements in order to encourage applicants in these strategically important areas of study.

If left unchecked, the decision to lift of the cap on AAB students could simply amount to universities offering disproportionately more places on cheaper-to-run arts courses in a bid to win higher levels of funding.

Whilst decreased fees will undoubtedly be a cause for celebration amongst prospective students, perhaps this constitutes better news for the future historian than it does for any of the next generation of budding scientists.