In defence of Durham’s ethical funding policy
Most readers will have seen the recent media interest in a leaked document linked to Durham University which was published on Wikileaks, including extensive coverage in last week’s Palatinate, as well as one or
two national papers and on the web.
This private document was an internal memo of the US Government’s State Department, which is concerned with issues of international relations. It included a subjective appraisal of academic applications which Durham University staff members had made to a US Government small grants programme in 2007. This was not a document into which the University had any input or was aware of, and contrary to any misleading inferences in some media coverage this document was in no sense a memo of understanding or negotiation.
Durham was successful in being awarded three grants from this programme, in competition with other institutions, to take forward the academic proposals we had submitted and we received this funding in 2009. The grants enabled our highly-regarded School of Government and International Affairs (SGIA) to bring high-profile figures from around the world to speak and engage in dialogue with each other and with our students and staff, to deepen mutual understanding on cultural, social and political issues in Iran and the widern Middle East. In summary, the three programmes promote debate on important issues for the future of the Iranian people and for international relations: “Building links between NGOs for training, networking, knowledge sharing and increased public awareness, with a goal of joint cooperation between Iran and US universities and NGOs working to empower women”; “Building links between NGOs for training, networking, knowledge sharing and increased public awareness, with a goal of joint cooperation between Iran and US universities and NGOs working to empower women”; and “Sharing UK/US academic views with leading Iranian seminarians.”
Durham University is home to students of 130 nationalities and our staff undertake research which has impact and benefits around the world. Diversity and the exposure to different ideas is part of what distinguishes a Durham education and why our graduates are so sought after by employers around the world. Like all leading universities, we receive funding from Governments, organisations and individuals in order to be able to carry out this research and to provide our students with the best possible education. Our Strategy sets out the University’s values, and a framework of ethics committees (with student representation on Council’s ethics committee) has been established to uphold these values. In particular, our processes aim to ensure academic freedom and that the source of funding has no influence on the outcomes of our research. This was the case for the US grants referred to in the leaked document: the funders of these programmes (of which the US State Department was only one) had no influence on who was invited to the seminars or on the nature or the outcomes of the debates.
The University is self-governing organisation with charitable purposes operating within the law of the UK. We are both grateful and proud of the fact that our students and our research are supported by governments, organisations and individuals from around the world. We expect our students, staff and visitors to have their own political, religious and cultural opinions, and debate these vigorously, irrespective of the views of the University as an organisation. There are two core values, freedom of speech and academic freedom, which in my opinion must be upheld by any University worth its name. Freedom of speech, tempered of course with respect for others, is fundamental to education, debate and the development of new ideas. Academic freedom provides the opportunity to carry out research into any important question and gives researchers the independence to draw whatever conclusion the research leads to so that new ideas and thinking can emerge independently of external political, religious or cultural constraints. In upholding these values we can ensure we fulfil our aim to contribute to ideas, dialogue, understanding and tolerance around the world.

