Politicians In a Pickle
If anyone saw Question Time the other day, they will have watched the Conservative Party Chairman, Eric Pickles, being mauled by an angry audience over the fact that he has a second home subsidised by the tax payer.
The rule is normally that MPs are given financial help with their second home, on the grounds that they need two in order both to work regularly in parliament and to serve their constituents somewhere else in the country. But the rules for London MPs are currently split: those representing an inner London constituency are not allowed this help, whereas outer London MPs are allowed it.
Mr Pickles is an outer London MP, so he is within the law. But his situation wasn’t helped by the Liberal Democrat Ed Davey telling the audience that he (also an outer London MP) refuses to take advantage of this rule because he thinks to do so would be immoral. This left Mr Pickles floundering in an attempt to justify the fact that he owns two homes in London. It was easily the most pathetic performance I’ve ever seen. He just kept digging. It was eerily similar to that episode of The Thick of It where Ben goes on Newsnight and blinks a lot. You couldn’t help imagining some Tory PR man yelling at the television. Afterwards, he looked as though he was ready to kill himself.
The odd thing is, Pickles is one of the least easy Tories to hate. The name, the tubby self-effacement, the fact that he doesn’t sound like he went to Eton. He’s not the obvious target for a public outburst. How will the rest of them manage in government?
It’s a commonplace that politicians are ‘out of touch’ or ‘all in it for themselves’, that they don’t know the price of milk and such like. But what we are going to see as the economy drains away is an unprecedented level of public anger and cynicism. A lot of politics, unfortunately, is about deflecting that kind of anger, and politicians are supposed to be good at it (better than Mr Pickles, anyway).
But politicians have never before had to face a public under the following combined circumstances: high unemployment rates, relatively high living expectations, a cultural ethos of nihilism and ennui, years suffering the twin evils of the 24-hour mass media and the sophisticated poltical PR that has responded to it (everyone is sick of spin), new levels of transparency in government and parliament (hence all the MP expenses stories), and the necessity for any government to make massive cuts in public services.
If the bereft look on the face of Eric Pickles is anything to go by, the Tories would be better off not winning the next election. More generally, the ‘Westminsiter Village’ is at some point going to have to deal in a more systematic manner with the gap between its own debates and those in the public. Maybe this is years of looking down on American populism coming back to haunt us? But, then, if we didn’t have elitism we wouldn’t have produced the eloquence of Dan Hannan, over whom American right-wing media has been obsessing in the last few days (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94lW6Y4tBXs). Call it the circle of life.
