Seriously sinister
The Pillowman
Castle Theatre Company
Assembly Rooms
Billed as a “searingly brilliant play”, The Pillowman had a lot to live up to. With such controversial content I hoped the show would not disappoint. Ben Salter and Patrick Neyman as Detectives Topolski and Ariel appeared as sinister black-suited sharks circling the handcuffed Katurian (Ben Starr). As the interrogation progressed it became clear that the script was not only profoundly dark but deeply funny.
Lines such as “you look f***ing stupid” (Topolski referring to Katurian’s wearing a bag on his head) elicited unprecedented chuckles from the audience.
Salter’s dry, heartless delivery of these early moments was timed to perfection, and the inherent blasé cruelty present in his voice and physicality was unnerving. At times dangerously still, at others explosive, Salter became the embodiment of totalitarian terror without ever crossing the line into stereotype.
Neyman too gave a disturbingly sadistic performance as Ariel. With little vocal or facial inflection and the casual air of something terrible lying just below the facade, the scenes between Ariel and Katurian were intensely unsettling.
Ben Starr’s performance as Katurian was nuanced and heartbreaking, Starr was born to tell stories. The audience were unable to take their eyes off him as he recounted his tales throughout the play. The breadth and depth of his vocal and emotional range was a pleasure to watch: he was quite simply mesmerising.
Complimenting the superb acting was the most inventive and interesting use of light and space I have seen in a Durham theatrical performance. One moment that excelled was ‘The Little Jesus Girl’ story, during which an impressive supporting cast (Stevie Martin, Tom Lyons, Adam Usden and Cassie Bradley) enacted the tale told by Starr. The slow and eerie downward head movements of Martin and Usden to symbolise their deaths were emphasised by a careful fade. Bradley’s silent scream and muffled sobs added to an already unbearable tension in the theatre which the audience is not likely to forget in a hurry.
A flaw in the production – a very minor one – was the somewhat awkward shift from fiction to reality. The pivotal moment in which it was revealed that Katurian had not found the corpse of his brother clutching a story in his hand but had found a tortured boy alive was somewhat glossed over, and I felt I was having to catch up for a few minutes. However, every other significant moment was directed and acted with such sensitivity.
The use of film to close the play was particularly effective. A close up of Starr’s eyes became oddly claustrophobic because we had just seen him die. As it panned out to include the also dead Michal, we were left with a tantalising vision of what-might-have-been before the inevitable slide towards violence.
The Pillowman was certainly a showcase of some of the boldest and most raw theatrical talent that Durham has to offer. The team must be congratulated on what will surely be remembered as one of the greatest achievements of Durham Student Theatre in many years.
