Mark Duggan’s death should not be glossed over

mark duggan 1

By Sam Courtney-Guy

A Comment article in the last Palatinate print edition discussed the controversy over Mark Duggan’s fatal shooting back in 2011, brought back into the media limelight recently when his killing was declared lawful after an inquiry.

The author made some reasonable points: Duggan’s death being undeserved does not make him a good person, and making him into a martyr foolishly forgets his dark past as a violent thug. But this quickly turned into a tirade that is typical of the worrying acquiescence shown towards the police when it deals with ‘bad guys’ in bad ways.

The writer deplored the supposed hypocrisy of those concerned over Duggan’s death in whilst society demands a “strong response to knife and gun crime and gang violence” – seemingly forgetting that shooting an unarmed man is gun crime.

Duggan’s death should not be glossed over as just an honest mistake

If we are going to give anyone a monopoly on violence, it is madness to let them get away with things like this. Duggan’s death should not be glossed over as just an honest mistake. This controversy illustrates a disturbing trend in our attitude towards policing and punishment: that it is acceptable to bend the rules when it comes to dealing with criminals.

We give gangsters jail time, not death sentences. The idea that Duggan’s criminal history somehow takes the edge off his shooting goes against the centuries of effort spent building up a just legal system in this country. The fact that many people have this mind-set certainly makes me worry about how fair the jury was to deem the killing lawful. Eight of those ten men and women in court somehow decided that the officer who shot the unarmed Duggan genuinely believed he was a threat.

British criminal courts only convict when guilt is beyond reasonable doubt; so the jury did not just believe it was possible that this policeman thought Duggan was armed, but that he had to think so. Given that the gun was found several metres away on the other side of a fence (and even the police eventually admitted that it must have been thrown there before Duggan got out of the car) it is beggar’s belief that the officer in question was totally justified in shooting – not just once, but twice.

Even if we forgive the police’s actions at the very moment of Duggan’s death, their behaviour afterwards is even more cause for concern

Whether we like it or not, our legal system can make mistakes, and accepting jury verdicts as indisputable truth is a dangerous path to go down. Even if we forgive the police’s actions at the very moment of Duggan’s death, their behaviour afterwards is even more cause for concern.

Both the officers involved and the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) flagrantly backtracked and U-turned on their story like a child that knows it has been naughty and tries to cover its tracks. They initially told the media that he had the gun in his hand, fired at them, and even briefly tried to have us believe that he managed to shoot an officer.

After the shooting, police did not undertake any internal review, and failed to question the officers involved in the shooting. Not only that, but those very officers then refused to be interviewed by the IPCC. This is not the behaviour of a trustworthy force out only to protect citizens; this is the behaviour of a crooked institution trying desperately to protect itself.

That there have been so few fatal mistakes by police is by no means evidence in favour of our bobbies. For every Mark Duggan, Ian Tomlinson and Jean Charles de Menezes that makes it onto our front pages, how many more shady police practices go undiscovered?

This is not the behaviour of a trustworthy force out only to protect citizens; this is the behaviour of a crooked institution trying desperately to protect itself

Of course, not all the police force is riddled with such dodgy behaviour and murky characters. But you cannot escape bad eggs in any organisation, or the occasional unintentional error. These should be wiped out quickly and with total impartiality, and if the police are not prepared to shine the light on themselves then we have little hope for this.

If we let this scandal slip past us just because a criminal has been wiped out of the picture, we lose yet another golden opportunity to reform our law enforcement for the better.

Photograph: Morteza Nikoubazl