The real loser at this election is democracy

ElectionSmall

By Sam Courtney-Guy

Despite what each side has told you over their election campaign, the victory of their opponents is probably not going to lead Britain into disaster. We’ve been fed a six-week diet of exaggeration: that Labour will push the economy into debt-ridden freefall, that the Conservatives will bring about an explosion in inequality and poverty, and so on. The reason these won’t happen isn’t because they’re necessarily right about each other’s policies, but that we probably won’t ever see their manifestos put in place. First Past the Post breeds this sort of situation because the two main parties rely on tactical voting to keep their decaying dominance in place, and a climate of broken promises because it never truly gives the public a chance to punish a party for misleading them.

If you don’t feel like voting, that’s alright. Don’t let anyone scold you over what people fought for, and so on. The men and women that died for democracy died for your representation, not for you to be guilt-tripped into choosing the lesser of several evils. Attractive promises about what one party will do, and the scary prospects of what their opponents might, leads us every five years to forget what our hearts and minds tell us and listen to the fear in our stomachs.

The fact that “I would vote X, but I’m going to vote Y to keep out Z” is something of a British catchphrase at election time is not the sign of a healthy democracy. It’s the sign of a system in which you are selling your share of democracy, or rather renting it out for five years in exchange for a futile hope that, one day, things might get better. We should be using our precious political freedom to demand a better system, and a change to the voting system would be a good start. Under First Past the Post, we are not represented equally, if at all. A vote in this election is a vote for this system.

More and more of the public are waking up to the fact that many of their political woes are down to FPTP. This might not be for reasons that you’re comfortable with: the chances are that everyone reading this dislikes at least one of the Green Party and UKIP – both of whom want to ditch it – and it’s fair to assume that many of their supporters are being wooed by Proportional Representation because it increases the chances of their favourite party being elected. Amongst our politicians, support for PR versus FPTP is split roughly along the lines of who would win or lose the most from either system: it’s not at all comforting to think that so much of the support for a new, more representative system comes from its spiritual nemeses of political tribalism and hunger for power.

Yet perhaps I’m being too cynical. Is it too hard to imagine both Greens and ‘kippers rallying under the flag of PR, both in the knowledge that it would bring more seats in Parliament to each other? Nevertheless, consensus would still be far from a clear run to democracy. First Past the Post is not the source of all our problems, but it’s one of them. I’m not talking about the advantages and disadvantages of other voting systems, or legitimate concerns that even under Proportional Representation we would be faced with corrupting influences on political parties.

What is most worrying is the terms on which this debate will be had. In the UK, we have a long, proven record of completely missing the point. When we held a referendum on AV (Alternative Vote) four years ago – a memory which has now all but faded – any mention of democracy was quickly drowned out by fruitless discussions of how much it would cost to implement and run. When Scotland went to vote on independence, they did so in a climate of scaremongering: both sides engaged in shouting matches over oil off the northern coastline and whether they would be financially better off in or out of the UK, not whether Scottish identity and ideological differences from the rest of the UK are distinct enough to merit a separate republic. When we talk about EU membership – and no doubt this will remain the case if we end up with a referendum in the next two years – we tend to trade narrow ideas about whether we’re economically better off in or out, not the legitimacy of EU government or the merits of the European project.

It’s not that the details don’t matter, or that the public don’t understand them, which they do. The problem is that they take centre stage because they make for better headlines, and short-term issues grab our attention far more easily than the fundamental questions because they’re so much less abstract. This is one of the very reasons why we have consistenly poor turnout, even in huge moments like this general election. Compare the abysmal turnout at the European Elections, where people don’t vote because they (rightly or wrongly) see no consequence to come from it, to the firestorm of enthusiasm on both sides of the Scottish independence referendum, where the electorate could feel their future swinging before them.

Things like ‘micro-costs’ and short-term economic gains and losses are utterly insignificant compared to the ideas of political justice and representation which are at stake here. These terms of debate aren’t just distracting, they’re a danger to the fabric of democracy. The moment we stop talking about principles and only talk figures is the moment people lose interest. This is what has happened over the course of this election: fighting over details of policy and personality has caused us to lose sight of the fact that the make-up the House of Commons and how it votes has shockingly little to do with what people in Britain actually believe.

So a shake-up to the electoral system would not solve all our problems straight away. But it would shake off the dusty web of tactical voting and tribalism which has held us back from moving towards a representative democracy. I don’t think it would be too optimistic to suggest that, under a system like PR, people’s ability to vote positively for their beliefs rather than negatively from their fears would mean that the allegiances of those filling the Commons benches come next election would represent the country that votes for them. And perhaps even more: that a loss of trust in some groups of politicians would mean that they would lose their votes and their power, instead of being propped up because they tell us that the other lot are even worse.

Photograph: Keith Ivey